Inderes’ Disclaimer can be found here. Detailed information about each share actively monitored by Inderes is available on the company-specific pages on Inderes’ website. © Inderes Oyj. All rights reserved.
Read transcripts of webcasts and audiocasts
Read transcripts of webcasts and audiocasts
Disclaimer: This is a machine-generated transcript and may contain inaccuracies.
Hello and good morning. I'm Pierre Cadena, and I'm joined by our chief financial officer, Michael Gerrow. Today we'll be speaking to our Q1 interim report, focusing on financials and our strategy and outlook. Q1 was a quarter of underperformance, with revenue from continuing operations totaling €16 million, representing a year-on-year decrease of 49%. Contributing factors include lackluster execution in our core operations. Stronger competition. Tightened marketing spending by operators. Recent Google Core updates that have adversely impacted the visibility and ranking of some of our sites, and a less favorable state launch rollout. In terms of the state launches in the quarter, we did have two states launch online sports betting. The first was Vermont on January 11th, and the second was in North Carolina on March 11th. The launch in Vermont was not materially impactful to our business, given the relatively small population size of the state. North Carolina, however, with an adult population of 8.5 million people, And you know, while it did not meet our expectations, it did provide a positive uplift for us and it was our strongest performing state in Q1. To help position the company for improved results in the second half of this year and beyond. This quarter, we announced significant internal and strategic changes. We began our shift from a geocentric operating model to one that will incorporate agile, product-focused teams with defined targets and operational and financial success. We are confident this alignment will help drive accountability and performance on a product-by-product basis. We've also strengthened our leadership across key functional areas such as technology, organic growth, SEO, and operations to help drive this transformation forward. Lastly, on the product and engineering front, we continue the development of our new technical platform and started to integrate it across our products. We expect a full rollout across our products to be completed in the second quarter of this year. Also in the quarter, I was appointed interim chief executive officer following the departure of Michael Daly in February. We also announced Manuel Stan will be joining us in July as our new chief executive officer. Upon Manuel's arrival, I will then step into the role of Chief Operating Officer. Lastly, I'm excited to announce that Michael Gerrow was appointed to Chief Financial Officer on April 15th. Mike has been with Catena for four years and is not only deeply familiar with how our business operates, but also aptly equipped to help push Catena Media forward as we transform the company for growth. With that, I will turn it over to Michael to present the financials in more detail. Thank you, Pierre, and good morning. Moving into our financial analysis, from a geographical split perspective,
we concluded the quarter at €14.3 million in revenue in North America, down from €28.9 million in revenue for the corresponding quarter last year. Adjusted EBITDA decreased to €5.4 million, 72% lower than last year, corresponding to a margin of 37%. Our North America revenue amounted to 90% of group revenue from continuing operations in the quarter. Looking at our segments. Sports was down 70% versus last year. The main cause of our underperformance is driven by increased competition, lower CPA rates in sports, and the addition of difficult comparables with the Ohio and Massachusetts launches from last year. Our North American casino business was also down. Versus Q1 2023 by 15%. But it is showing signs of a turnaround, with a 12% quarter-on-quarter growth versus Q4 of 2023. Quarter on quarter. Casino growth is a reflection of our aggressive program and measures currently underway to restore the business to profitable growth in the second half of 2024. Looking at the rest of the world, which mostly contains our Latam business, esports, and APAC businesses. We saw revenue of 1.7 million, a decrease of 36% versus last year. Adjusted EBITDA, however, increased by 58%, which can be attributed to streamlining APAC and the remaining European operations combined with profitable growth of the esports business. We are seeing profitable growth in key products in this area, including esports in Slovakia. Continuing into our segment performance, we saw a very large decline in our sports revenue from 6.1 million to 19.2 million in the previous year. Our casino revenue decreased by 20% versus the previous year. However, a sizable portion of that is attributed to historic revenue share players from our APAC and remaining European businesses. While our North American casino revenue decreased by 15% compared to last year. We are pleased to see the previously mentioned 12% growth compared to Q4 2023. With growth in most of our regulated states. This is an early validation of the turnaround strategies that are already underway. We are also continuing to see a positive impact in the casino segment from our broad social and sweeps casino footprint. This burgeoning segment is capitalizing on the slower than originally expected regulated casino launches in the various states, giving us an opportunity for continued growth. Continuing on to our cost developments, we continue to invest in technology. Sub-affiliation, media partnerships, and paid media PR will touch on this in more detail in his outlook and strategy portion of the presentation. Costs in North America decreased by 7% and accounted for 63% of the total group cost base from continuing operations. We had higher direct costs related to media partnerships signed in 2023 that were not active in Q1 of 2023. Not all of these partnerships have been profitable for us and are contributing to our negative sports EBITDA contribution. Prior cost savings initiatives helped offset our investments in AI and technological platforms. Items affecting comparability in the quarter were €1 million. We will focus on cost efficiency per product through this transformation initiative. Despite consecutive quarters of poor financial results. The receipts from proceeds of our divested assets through the strategic review continue to put us in a very healthy financial position. Net interest-bearing debt decreased by 56% to €10.1 million. We have a strong net cash position, including our future proceeds from divested assets. Our focus is to continue reducing debt and investing in strategic investments. The leverage ratio is 0.99 versus 0.44 last year. Looking at our capital structure, We currently have no outstanding financial commitments relating to prior acquisitions. Our cash balance at the end of the year was €23.4 million. And we're reporting a net debt of €10.1 million at the end of March. If we include future proceeds from divested assets, We have a net cash position of €11.9 million. As announced in January, we successfully completed a written procedure and partial repayment of half of the nominal value of our bonds. The total outstanding nominal value of the bond is €27.5 million, of which Catena Media holds €6.15 million. The bonds now have a maturity date of June 9, 2025, to be in line with their expected proceeds from divested assets. To date, scheduled payments for assets sold have been received according to plan. And with that, I will now hand back over to Pierre to give us an update on the strategy and outlook.
Thanks, Mike. The number of state and provincial launches in North America has decreased in each of the past three years, with only four launches in 2023 and two launches in the first quarter of this year. Additionally, each of the six aforementioned launches has been for sports betting and none for casino. As previously reported, our business has historically focused on launches, and although North Carolina did present itself as a sizable opportunity based on the adult population, it is still smaller than that of Ohio and Massachusetts, which launched in the first quarter of last year. Despite the activity of state launches in recent years, there is still an exciting opportunity ahead as it fuels future legislation, I should say. In fact, the sports betting and casino opportunities are only 50% and 16% penetrated, respectively, representing additional upside in our total addressable market. This being said, we do not anticipate any further market launches in 2024, which is to be expected to some degree, particularly given that legislative activity is typically slower in election years in the US, with activity regaining momentum thereafter. As such, we cannot rely on state launches to be the only driver of our growth in the upcoming quarters. We will be focusing our efforts to get more out of our existing products. Product development. I am confident our shift to a product-first, success metrics-driven, and outcome-oriented operating model, which I touched on earlier, will position us well to drive revenue organically, both at the top of the funnel with increased traffic and at the bottom of the funnel through optimized conversion. Additionally, we've seen recent success in turning around and optimizing some of our casino products which Mike mentioned, and we will take our learnings and findings from these initiatives and extend them to some of our core sports brands to drive results. Management changes. Earlier, I spoke about how we are continuing to strengthen our leadership in key functional areas. This focus must go beyond the executive leadership team. We must have leaders and operators across our extended management team. They have the passion, knowledge, and capabilities to execute and thrive in our product-led operating model. Embedded at the center of this model will be a best-in-class data reporting and business intelligence function that will enable our product teams to be metrics-driven with clearly defined targets and definitions of success as their North stars. Supporting these efforts will be our technology. In Q1, we started integrating a new in-house developed platform into our owned and operated sites. And we expect the rollout will be completed in Q2. Once complete, we'll be able to efficiently serve ads and other monetization features and deploy calls to action across our sites via a single platform. Thereafter, in subsequent quarters, the platform will continue to evolve as our product and engineering teams introduce additional features and functionality. We previously reported momentum with our AI joint venture, which was established in Q4 last year. We successfully launched the MVP version of our AI platform in Q1, and we are now in the eighth week of our go-to-market plan. The platform is currently integrated into two of our sites, assisting our content teams and reducing the time it takes to produce, edit, and publish domain-authoritative content. It's still early, of course, but we are seeing healthy leading indicators for site sustainability, content creation, efficiency, and SEO metrics. We are also on track to launch in the second quarter, a new platform that will help accelerate our efforts to reach a new cohort of sports bettors and casino players through sub-affiliation. Once complete, our operator partners will also see utility benefits in the form of more robust and automated compliance reporting, invoicing, and payment workflows. Lastly, media partnerships. We will continue to grow, optimize, and expand our media partnerships this year. We have the luxury of bringing deep content and SEO expertise, in addition to our learnings from existing and previous partnerships, to maximize value for Catena Media and our media partners. Key takeaways. We experienced lower revenue in North America due partly to increased competition and lower marketing spending by operators. The revenue impact was strongest in our sports segment, and we have measures underway to address this underperformance and return to growth. We've seen initial signs of improvement in our casino segment, which generated a 12% increase in revenue quarter on quarter. Organic growth is expected to resume in the second half of this year, with full-year adjusted EBITDA still expected to be in the range of 20 to €30 million. This is expected to be driven by continued growth in our casino products. More profitable media partnership operations. The rollout of our technology platforms and a turnaround of our flagship sports products. Significant ongoing technology products and AI investments are ongoing. And the launch of a new technical platform will be fully integrated into all of our sites in Q2, which will drive operational efficiencies and help pave the way for new products like AI sub-affiliation and paid media. We'll now open it up for questions.
If you wish to ask a question, please dial the pound key five on your telephone keypad to enter the queue. If you wish to withdraw your question, please dial the pound key six on your telephone keypad. If you are listening via webcast, use the message board to ask a written question. The next question comes from Oscar Reconquest from ABG. Please go ahead.
You asked. Good morning, and thanks for taking my questions. So my first one would just be on the reiterated full-year guidance of 20 to 30 million euros in EBITDA. So, uh, I mean, the Q1 numbers came in at just below 2 million. And uh, as you mentioned in the presentation as well, um, this is the only quarter where we have state launches, which I mean, obviously supports a little bit, uh, I guess that it's a bit more revenue share tilted than previous state launches, but still, I mean, it came in at 19% of, I mean, NDC is the worst on revenue share contracts. Doesn't really seem to be like a steep increase. So could you just talk a little bit more about the trajectory, uh, for the year to reach 20 million when you had 2 million now in Q1, which is a pretty, you know, seasonally strong quarter. So, uh, is there like a major impact from the euros, the Copa America or anything else that we should be aware of, uh, that you think will, I mean, help you reach the, uh, the targets of, uh, at least 20 million euros. Thanks.
Hey, Oscar. Thank you. Um. You know. Yeah, what I would say is we have a number of exciting opportunities and initiatives that, you know, we are currently executing. Um, you know, this includes looking deeply at our core organic SEO business and making the requisite strategic management and operational adjustments to allow us, frankly, to get more out of our existing products and drive organic growth. I spoke a little bit about the bottom of funnel, uh, optimizations that I, that I think we can do, and we've got to get better at making sure that we're getting the most out of our products. And even when there are no new state launches or, uh, traffic is even going down, there's still a revenue opportunity that we can grab by optimizing our products through conversion rate. So that will be, you know, in part, um, something that we will be focused on in the second half. You know, I will say, you know, as I as I mentioned about the opportunities and initiatives they each have, various, you know, different starting points, resource requirements, and levels of effort to complete. You know, as a result, the endpoints, you know, may impact and vary across the portfolio from timing and financial contributions, perspectives. And so, um, just given the timing of some of these initiatives, they are starting to complete in Q2 and come online in the second half of this year. And so we'll start to see some impacts here in Q2. But we'll, you know, we'll we'll see even more impact, including a return to growth in the second half of this year when several projects complete, new businesses come online. And, uh, the product operating model alignment, which I mentioned earlier, when that starts to bear fruit as well, um, I clearly have to ensure that the teams execute at its highest levels of their highest levels to get there. But we are progressing well, uh, as we head into the second half of this year.
All right. Thank you. And I mean, as you mentioned, I think I mean, obviously you're targeting organic growth in H2, uh, as comps or easing a little bit as well. Um, so just I mean, looking sequentially, I think you're still at, you know, Q3 2023 levels. So, is it to be interpreted that, you know, sort of sequentially from the new sort of starting point that will expect to see a gradual improvement from these efforts? Uh, during I mean, H2 and it's not just driven by comps, because, I mean, obviously you have to um, I guess that, you know, the cost base should be starting to flatten out a little bit after the AI investments and, and so on. And that, I mean, the trajectory towards the 20 million euros in EBITDA for the full year should be, you know, revenue, uh, growth driven. Is that how to interpret.
Yeah. I don't think you're far off, Oscar. I would segment it in a few ways. The product operating model has a clear focus on success. Definitions of success will allow us on a product-by-product basis to really understand the profitability of these products going forward. And, you know, where, perhaps the cost base is not aligned with our expectations of future growth. And clearly, we'll have to make some adjustments there. Um, I would say secondly, you're right, we do have favorable comparables coming up later this year. So that will certainly help. That being said, I don't think that is at all the reason for optimism. It was more to do with many of the initiatives and the opportunities that we've been executing since I joined the business. And, um, we'll have taken time to develop, come online. And, frankly, they will be live and operational in the second half of this year. And so, just by the nature of those businesses coming online, we will have, uh, more, I guess, shots on goal, so to speak, to make sure that we are driving revenue growth in the second half of this year.
Just the next question, on the revenue share transition, you're at 19% of NDCs sent on revenue share contracts. I think it was 16% in Q4. So a little bit of improvement, maybe driven by North Carolina. Um, but it was, I mean, still, I think it was around 23% in Q3. So you just talk a little bit about the shift towards revenue share and sort of the pace of that. Do you expect that to increase further or is this sort of a stabilized level around 20%?
Yes, I mean, first I'll iterate what has been mentioned. I should reiterate what has been mentioned in previous quarters. Strategically, we believe. The right, and sort of, air quotes around 'right'. The right revenue share agreements provide long-term value. That better aligns our upside with high player value, right? As mentioned previously, the quality and value of our referrals have long been one of Catena's competitive advantages. That being said, we're continuously evaluating the financial and strategic trade-off between CPA revenue, which, as you know, provides a near-term financial impact, and revenue share agreements, which come at a higher aggregate value but will take longer to manifest given the nature of those agreements. And we'll continue to move in the direction that frankly maximizes our business. At that particular point in time, and again, when I mention the right revenue share agreements, it not only means securing the right deal terms but also aligning with the right operators upon which to build a long-term relationship. But you hit the nail on the head, right? We're seeing some state openings. You know, that's another factor. And so, I think that was partly a driver of an increased revenue share index this quarter, given North Carolina. But all of those are factors contributing to the evolution of our revenue share-based NDCs over time. We don't necessarily have a target. It will continue to ebb and flow based on factors often outside of our control as well, which I've just mentioned.
Perfect, thank you. I think I just have one more question. Maybe two. Just a quick one; maybe to Michael. I think we've seen a significant shift towards shared central operations in adjusted EBITDA losses. So, the cost base is obviously a factor. Can we just talk a little bit about how representative the shared central costs are at the moment when we look at the 37% EBITDA margin in North America? What is the main driver behind the rapid increase in the cost base in shared central operations instead of the divisions?
Hi, Oscar. Thanks for the question. As part of our move towards a product-focused approach, we've already had some success in reducing some of our North American costs. That is what you are seeing there. Obviously, the direct costs have increased. This includes a 10% reduction in our internal content team headcount in February of 2024, which was not realized across the entirety of the quarter. But it does have an impact. We've also invested in our centers of excellence in areas that include technology and a few other areas. This means that our shared centralized teams are now more actively supporting the North American business needs, and they have indeed increased slightly. It's also important to note that when we look at the comparables in Q1 2023, we had accounting treatments of discontinued operations, some bad debt reversals, incentive plan reversals, and so forth. And that was all based on the EBITDA contributions of the divested businesses. So I'd say that referencing our Q4 2023 and the transition to Q1 2024 is more of a useful comparison, to be honest, than going year over year from that perspective.
Okay. Perfect. That's very helpful. Just one final question, if you can answer. I think the positive item in the report is the sequential casino revenue. I think this was highlighted in your presentation as well. Can you talk a little bit about that? Do you have anything to say about the trend going into April? I noticed that an April revenue figure wasn't provided, but just anything on the underlying momentum there.
Yes, unfortunately. I mean it's both a positive and a negative. We are now able to report much earlier. And so unfortunately, at this early point in the month, we can't provide that update just yet.
Got it. That was all from me. Thank you very much, guys.
Thank you, Oscar.
Thanks, Oscar.
So with that, I believe that's the last of our calling questions that people have provided to us. So, I will ask a few of the written questions that have come in, and I'll pose those right now. So, Pierre, one of the questions is, what are your thoughts on the recent changes in management?
Underpinning the recent management changes has been our belief in shifting to an agile, product-focused operating model, where our product teams will have defined targets for operational and financial success. I am confident this will help position Catena Media for future growth and prepare for this shift. We have strengthened the management team and, as you know, we have commenced this rollout. But as I've mentioned earlier in the presentation, we also need to strengthen our extended management team to ensure we have the appropriate personnel, capabilities, and mindsets required to execute successfully in this new manner and in this new operating environment.
Thank you, Peter. The next question is, you previously stated that Catena Media expects to return to organic growth in H2 2024, with five months of the year past. Sorry, how are you progressing towards this goal? This builds on what Oscar just asked.
Yes, very similar, I would say. And I'll use my previous answer as the jumping-off point. I mean, the short answer is that I believe we are progressing quite well. We do have a number of opportunities and initiatives that we are currently executing. You can categorize them. Some are certainly at the corporate level. And we've talked a little bit about some of our technology projects along the way. But there are quite a few compelling business vertical opportunities that get into our business segments: casino, sports, media partnerships. Some of which I and, you know, Michael, you as well, have highlighted earlier are taking some of those learnings from our success on the casino side and now starting to implement and roll them out into some products on the sports side that need some optimization, but yeah, it's a similar answer to what I mentioned to Oscar: these opportunities all have different starting points. They have different resource requirements and levels of effort to complete. Some will start to ramp up more immediately than others. But I would say that our optimism for the second half of this year is largely due to the factors that I've previously mentioned, in terms of our alignment from an operating model perspective, but also the fact that we will see many of these initiatives and opportunities start to come online in the second half of this year.
Thank you, Pierre. Another follow-up question, which is: Will you mainly leverage your presence in the US when it comes to sub-affiliation growth? Or we expand to GEOs where we've been present before or sold assets.
Yeah, I don't necessarily think our sub-affiliation business is going to operate outside our core markets. Um, you know, we are obviously very focused on the North American market and regulated and emerging regulated markets like Latin America. Um, and this is where I do see the opportunity for the sub-affiliation business as well. Um, you know, the thesis for our vision for sub-affiliation, both from a market opportunity perspective and a product is very much about our conversations with operators, but also our hypothesis about operators' need to reach a different type of cohort. Um, right. That is a little bit more top of the funnel, a little bit more challenging to reach in the classic affiliation sense of our business. Um, and so we believe sub-affiliation allows us to expand our total addressable market by reaching a cohort of casino players and sports bettors that, perhaps, was previously inaccessible by leveraging entities like content creators, streamers, and personalities that have really engaged audiences. Um, and perhaps affiliates that are not considered classic affiliates today. And so we're excited about that opportunity. And it's very much a North American focus. But we do believe that it also has some applicability into other emerging regulated markets where we will operate as well.
All right.
And then there are a couple of questions that came in focused on my area of the business. So I'll ask those and then answer them myself. So it's possible you have the opportunity to buy back the hybrid bonds after next quarter. Do you intend to do that to decrease costs or use the money elsewhere? So my response to that is we have a focus on our debt and equity instruments, and we are continuously evaluating the best way to use our capital. That includes both focus on our senior bonds that mature in June 2025 and our hybrid capital securities. Currently, we are also investing in the business for future growth. And then there's a second question that is kind of a follow-up to that, that I will now answer, which is regarding the hybrid securities that mature next year. Do you believe that you will extend the maturity of the securities, and by doing so, will you reclassify them as a liability rather than equity? The hybrid capital securities are classified as equity according to IFRS standards, a classification that will remain unchanged. The securities will not mature next year as they are perpetual, meaning that they do not have a maturity date. But there is the possibility for a significant step-up in the interest regarding that instrument. So we will, of course, evaluate the best capital structure for the business with that in mind. And then there's one final question that has come in that's going to go back to Pierre now. And that's.
How.
We're communicating to media affected by the recent Google update. And does your future AI platform conflict heavily with Google's focus on no AI-generated content?
Yes, I'll speak a little bit more generally. Um, there were, uh, several. Well, I would say well, I'll speak a little bit more generally, but several times a year. Um, you know, Google makes significant broad changes to its search algorithms and systems, and these changes form the core updates, um, which are sort of underlying the question. These core updates are designed to ensure Google is presenting the most helpful and reliable search results to its users. Um, as a result, Google may change um, its preference criteria, and in doing so, new sites could be placed in top positions for keywords, while other sites might fall in terms of visibility and rankings. And so I'm not sure exactly which update the question was referring to, but the updates from November of last year and in March of this year were, I would say, particularly hard-hitting for our sites. Um, our SEO and content teams have been working hard to recover and reset. Um, and some products recover faster than others. The update in March was accompanied by an announcement from Google about. Um, a few things I'll mention too, which was scaled content abuse, which is meant to deal with low quality, unoriginal, and automated or automatically generated content. Um, so I'll put that to the side for one second, because I know there was AI that was part of the question. Um, but the other thing that I'll highlight was future enforcement of site reputation abuse, which actually started, um. On May 6th, or sorry on May 7th. Um, which could, um, you know, have some impacts on our media partnerships and other types of editorial collaboration across the industry. Um, and so obviously, yes, we have to consistently monitor, um, you know, what, what is Google's impact on our sites? I mean, um, in terms of the AI platform, I think, you know, for us, um, and, and you know, how our rollout has been. I mean, this is, uh, sort of how we have structured our, uh, our go-to-market around that. Um, and so we are, you know, consistently, um, uh, looking at, uh, and evaluating our, uh, rollout across things like, uh, site oil output efficiency, um, and, um, and SEO metrics, um, and, and other things. But, um, I would say that, um, yeah, sort of site sustainability. Uh, but so far we've seen generally an improvement across those metrics broadly week on week. And we've been pleased with that. That said, it's still very early in our deployment, and there's much more work and enhancement across our product roadmap to do, um, particularly making sure that the underlying model can produce a variety of content across different sports and output formats. So we'll continue to monitor that along the way. Uh, and we're, you know, given the fact that we've, um, been in the business of affiliation where we're sort of, you know, very accustomed to, uh, dealing with these, uh, Google updates along the way.
All right. Thank you, Pierre. That concludes the questions that we have both in written and from people on the line. So with that, I think we can call it a day.
Thanks, Mike. I have some closing remarks for me if I may. Um, Q1 was a disappointing quarter. And we recognize this. We have our work cut out for us. However, we also have a number of exciting opportunities and initiatives that I alluded to that we are currently executing. That fuels our optimism for growth in the second half of this year. Our recent management changes, which we will continue to build on, and our shift to an agile, product-focused operating model, where our product teams will have defined targets for operational and financial success, collectively underpin what will be a hyperfocus on execution, accountability, and profitable revenue growth in the coming quarters. We will keep you updated, and we will have more to share in Q2 across each of our focus areas, which again include product development, our people, technology and AI investments, and our media partnerships. We thank you for your time today and we look forward to speaking again soon.



















