Inderes’ Disclaimer can be found here. Detailed information about each share actively monitored by Inderes is available on the company-specific pages on Inderes’ website. © Inderes Oyj. All rights reserved.
Read transcripts of webcasts and audiocasts
Read transcripts of webcasts and audiocasts
Disclaimer: This is a machine-generated transcript and may contain inaccuracies.
So, good morning, everybody. Thanks for finding your way to Stockholm today or joining online. My name is Ingo Mittleman, and as the head of European Investor Relations at Verve, I'd like to cordially welcome you to this year's Capital Markets Day of our company. After intense weeks of planning, my whole team and I are really thrilled to finally have you here as our guests today. As usual, we've prepared some sophisticated deep dives into the most recent developments at Verve. From an operational and financial perspective, we offer valuable industry insights and sessions with high-level tech experts from our group. First up, let me present today's speakers to you. Representing our company's executive team, you will meet today. You will meet today. Remco Westerman, our CEO; Christian Duce, our CFO; and Michelle Allen, our CBO. And Paul Hatton, the CTO of our subsidiary, DataSet. And then we're very proud to have an international guest speaker with deep industry insight. Eric Seufert is going to do today's keynote. He's a media strategist, quantitative marketer, and author. And I'm really looking forward to his speech. He came all the way from the US today. What can you expect from Verve today on this Capital Markets Day? The day will be split into two parts. So we have basically two sessions. The first will be the business update, which will be run by Remco and Christian, covering the commercial update and the financial update. After this, we'll have an extensive Q&A session, which can also be followed online. Then after the lunch break, we're coming up with our expert chat sessions. The keynote I just mentioned. As well as deep dives into idealist advertising and AI in advertising. And now I'm handing you over to Remco Westermann, the CEO of Verve Group, who will lead you through the first part of today's Capital Markets Day. Remco. The stage is all yours.
Thank you. Good morning everybody. People here in the room but also online. Yeah, I would like to take you through the business update, starting with our equity story. Most here in the room and also many online know the company. So for some, it will be a bit repetitive. But I think it's always good to realize what we are aiming for, where we are, and what's our story? Starting with the market. Advertising is a very diverse, very crowded market, I would even say. And it's becoming more and more complex; where advertising started with a few newspapers, then radio, and a few TV stations, the diversity has become enormous. We still have radio, we still have television. But there are a lot of different social channels that have emerged. And here you see basically the life cycle of advertising. Many of those channels, like traditional television, are experiencing a decline. Why should you send one ad to everybody if you can send it on a digital TV, connected TV individually per household? So you see that, let's say, some channels are going down, some channels are still in a growth phase, and we have the emerging channels. Emerging channels. Is that what we are focusing on? The advantage of emerging channels is that market positions are not yet taken, or at least are quite young, and the markets are growing. And working in a growth market, of course, is much more exciting than working in a market that's declining. So, the channels that we're talking about include mobile, the personal device, and connected TV. So the old TV set, but now digitalized retail media. Coming up a lot. Amazon came up, I mean, making losses over many years and now being, let's say, the gigantic online retailer, but also traditional retailers like Walmart, Circle K, and many others are really getting into this space. Why not make money from the customer contacts that you have? Why not help the CPGs, so the consumer goods producers, bring people into the store to decide or to help them make a different decision on the product choice? Then digital out-of-home, the screens outside. It was also previously someone going around and posting those things, and now it is really digital. Getting more digital and a digital audio podcast, for example. Also getting in. So those are the channels that we're concentrating on. A bit about the market. We talk about a huge market, spending $1.1 billion on advertising. Worldwide per year in the US, over $1,200 is spent per head on advertising. 600 million of that is digital. So there is still a part that is dedicated to traditional television, especially. And in the digital part, you see a very big portion is mobile. Mobile SEC is a growth sector. It's growing nicely. The most personal device is already set, and it's 96% of our revenues. So mobile is really where we are focusing on. And then within mobile, it's mostly in-app. But we also do mobile web, then Connected TV is also a large segment, still smaller. And if you compare to linear, it's still small compared to linear. And that means also in the future there will be a lot more connected TV happening and then desktop. That's already more in what we say is the mature segment. So that's also what we're not concentrating on. We can do it because sometimes you need it to fulfill a campaign for an agency. But it's a small part of our revenues, and that's where Google and many others have taken strong positions. Talking about our main market, the US. The US accounts for nearly 80% of our revenues, precisely 79%. So it's an important market. Why are we so big in the US? It has a bit to do with how we started via acquisitions in the advertising part, but it also relates to our operations in the US. Its scaling is much easier. In Europe, you really have to go country by country, dealing with language rules and agencies, as everything is much more local, and the same holds true for Asia where often the CPM is lower. So the prices per ad are lower, and also for Latam, where we have the same, where the countries are maybe bigger, but let's say the revenues overall per country are smaller. So the US is a super interesting market for us. It's growing. You see here mobile expectations growing 10% per year. I'll get to market growth later in the presentation because there are always some hiccups in growth, even though there is continuous growth overall. And in the US, we're super proud that we have been able to build a strong position. iOS Apple's ecosystem in-app. We're seen as the number one market share-wise. That doesn't mean we have a 20 or 30% market share. There are still a lot of players in the market, and while our overall market share may not be huge, we are number one. That helps us to open a lot of doors on the trust index. Last presentation, we were number one. Now we're number three. So it's also, I mean, measuring is not always easy in those things, but I'm super happy that we are seen as one of the top recognized, trusted parties in the market. That helps a lot. Advertising is about trust. There's a lot of fraud, and, let's say, a lack of transparency. In that context, being trusted brings significant advantages and assistance. Regarding our business model, we are a tech company. We are running a tech platform. We match the advertiser with the publisher. I talk about digital channels, so all the matching is digital and it's much more complex than this picture. But we want to show basically that what we try to do is get the best result for the advertiser. Often working with his agency and then achieving the best results for the publisher, which means the highest price per ad, leads to a good fill rate. And for the advertiser, it's really about reaching the right target group in the most efficient way. A bit more complex. So what's happening? If you open a page, there is an ad on that page, or there's an ad spot on that page. And while you open the page, we receive the information that this ad is for sale. We technically connect it to the publisher. We have a contract. So this information comes to us, the ad request comes to us, we enrich it with data, and we make it available to the demand side. That's our supply side. The platform is doing that. On the demand side, you have a demand-side platform where several advertisers or agencies input their requirements. I want to reach a certain target group, a certain price per ad, certain, how to say, other targets, viewability, attention rate, those kinds of things. That's what they put in the system. And then there's a bidding between the two. The highest bidder wins. The ad from the highest bidder is being rendered. So in this case, it would be Adidas, and the Adidas ad is winning. Discuss prices for every 1,000 ads. CPM is the term used to refer to this, and the whole process has to happen in less than 100 milliseconds, because during the time that the page is loading, we have to complete the auction process and ensure that the ad is shown before the page is fully loaded. Otherwise, you have an empty ad spot and that's a waste of money for everybody. It's not only fast, we also handle a large volume. We serve 2 to 5 billion ads per day, and that's all happening there at the heart of the technology. And I'll come to our migration project a bit later on the slides. But we are really focused on innovation and efficiency, constantly improving our systems and strategies to stay ahead in the market. We started by acquiring some companies. We brought them together. We are integrating those into a single platform. And that single platform is managing both the supply side platform and the demand side platform. Just specify. Value chain. So we say we want to do everything between the advertiser and the publisher, which means that we have the full technology stack. So we have the DSP. We have an SSP, and we have the marketplace and the bidding part in the middle. If you look at the financial part of it, it's the advertiser who pays, and the agency then pays the money for the ads. And sometimes they mark up the prices for the advertiser, of course, mostly. From $100 that's paid, roughly 20% goes to the DSP, roughly 20% to the SSP, and roughly 10% goes toward data bidding, matching, etc. . So, 50% is taken by the chain, and 50% goes to the publisher. That's not a lot, you would say. If you then look, for example, at the Department of Justice files for the Google investigation, you see that Google takes 80% of the margin on external volume. So this sector is still not very margin efficient, I would say. And there are a lot of point solution parties that only do DSP or only do SSP. If you do the whole chain, you can become more efficient, you can make more margin, but you can also give to the publisher and to the advertiser. So that's an important point. It's a market that is not cost-sensitive at the moment. The market is really focused on finding the best matches for selling the ads. There's still a lot of unsold inventory and a lot of poor targeting remains. So that's more important even than the margins. But of course, margins also play a role. That's what we're doing when we enter this market. We were looking, hey, there are many parties here, but there are also many inefficiencies. But what's really changing in this market, and what's changing is privacy. Privacy is becoming more and more important. Being a European-based company, Stockholm-based, Sweden-based, we became aware of GDPR very early on in Europe. Caused a lot of, I would say, emotions. And if you ask a consumer, do you give consent that your data is being used? 80% say no. And there are differences between countries. But it's a rough number. But by far, the majority says no. That means that the advertising market is being disrupted. It's changing. The advertising market, specifically the digital advertising market, was used to targeting with cookies. If I have a cookie, I can build a profile because I see this cookie all the time coming back. I can say this person is interested in sports, this person has a certain profile, and I know when an ad comes from a phone, for example, if this person is present, I have to send this ad to maybe Adidas or somebody else who's looking for sports goods. That changes if there's no consent, if there's no identifier, I need to do targeting differently. We saw that as a disruption of the market, and when we started getting into advertising, we said that's really the big opportunity to go for. Later today, Michelle and Paul will go more in depth, but ideally, targeting is crucial. So, targeting without IDs is something that we really focus on and that has given us a strong market position. It differentiates us. And you see here, with iOS and Apple, we have really been able, as you saw the market share before, but we have also been able to really grow our revenues in this part. We've developed a solution for this. It's one of our ideal solutions. But we also see that Android is moving in that direction and also mobile web, etc. . We already see movements in that direction. So the ideal scenario is becoming more important. And that's where we really focus on differentiating a bit about the mix. What are we doing? I said mobile is very strong with 65,000 apps where we integrated mobile, accounting for 96% of our revenues. Connected TV. We have a lot of supply. We reached 200 million connected TV screens. There’s not a lot of differentiation. In connected TV. That's not only a problem for us, but for most parties. And we are working on that because we also want to extend our mobile. It's now 4%, but we want to increase it, which means we need to work more on competitive advantages, especially our strong data position that we obtain from mobile based on IP addresses. We can use that same data towards households. So that's what we're working on to also grow our CTV, our connected TV reach over 2.5 billion consumers. We have 954 large software clients by the end of Q2. Christian will cover that later in this presentation. Customer numbers. And we deliver 1 trillion ad impressions. We did 1 trillion ad impressions in the last 12 months. Demand supply. We started with more supply-focused strategies where the data is centered around the supplies provided by the publisher, which is where you get the ads. But we would like, as I showed before, to have equality between the two. Demand and supply. Because if you really get every dollar that comes from your own demand side or your own supply, you're most efficient. I showed the efficiencies before. We're not there yet. Last year with June Group, we made a significant move forward on the demand side to also organically grow faster. But it's 25% demand side, 75% supply. Ideally, we would get to 50/50 in the US. I already mentioned the 79% US market, 9% Europe, and 12% for the rest of the world and mobile. I mentioned the other channels already, they're there. You don't see them. They're still very small in digital out-of-home, retail media, and digital audio. But they're also growing. And also, we're building positions there. A bit of history. We started as a publisher. A games publisher started this almost 13 years ago. We have been growing every year. We have been growing our revenues. We have been growing our EBITDA. We transitioned from a publisher, which is a very, very difficult position to grow organically, towards an advertising company. With that, we renamed the company from Gamigo to Media and Games Invest, and then to Verve Group. Now we are an advertising company, even though we still have a bit of gaming, but it's under 10%. So we are really focused on being an advertising company. Last year, we achieved a 36% revenue growth, a 30% EBITDA margin, and we're here to continue growing. That was a bit about our equity story—how we grow. Now, moving on to the commercial update for Q2. I'll cover the numbers and headlines and then Christian will go more in detail. And normally at Capital Markets Day, we, let's say, come here with all the numbers as a surprise, or let's say, show them for the first time. We already went out on Thursday night with new guidance. And on Friday morning with our Q2 numbers, I'll be coming to that in a minute. But we had more issues on our platform unification than we expected, and it lasted longer. It cost a bit more revenue, and that also led us to the conclusion that we have to change our guidance for this year. Not happy with that, but yeah, it's running a company and it's not always a straight line, but the company is stronger than before. Unification is now complete. I'll come to that later in the presentation, but that's the reason that the numbers were already out. But nevertheless, we achieved a 10% increase in revenue and a 1% rise in adjusted EBITDA. We reached a 28% EBITDA margin leverage at 2.5. So on the high side, we are where we want to be with 22% software client growth. That's overall growth. The large clients didn't grow that fast, but we achieved a 98% retention rate. So our customers generated less revenue, but they stayed. And that's very important. So a very good retention rate. As Christian mentioned, we'll cover that later in the presentation. What are the main highlights? And I mentioned it already before, I would start with number three: platform unification. We are a tech company, and a tech company has a tech platform. And actually, when we started this, we did acquisitions and had several tech platforms. And our biggest part of the business, as I showed before, is mobile. It's in-app and it's our supply side. We had previously been integrating supply side platforms into two platforms. Of the acquisitions that we did, those two big platforms were integrated in Q2. And that was not without pain, as you see on the slide. Um, it lasted longer, and the issues were a bit more significant. I'll go further into detail later in the presentation. But it hurt us. And that means that we had less revenue and that we had more cost. And that is what you see in the numbers. So that is basically one point. The good thing is that the unification is now complete, and we are growing with a single in-app platform, which is much more efficient than before. And we have always said if we do acquisitions, and we already said that when we did gaming acquisitions, you need to integrate those companies. If you keep them independently, if you keep the platform's technology independently, it's very inefficient and it becomes more and more difficult to manage at a certain point. So I'm super happy that we did it. I'm super happy that we're out of it. But it really hurt. Then Liberation Day impact number one. Yeah. The market is a bit softer. The market is not overwhelmingly positive. And if you look at the guidance or also at the reports from our competitors, from people in the sector, you see that the market is not strong. But I'm not here to blame the market for our Q2. We had a one-time effect. And in this market, even though it's weaker, we can grow. Yeah, we had some weaker customers. On the other hand, you can compensate for it by acquiring new customers and retaining other customers. So market is a bit weaker. It's not 'wow'. But it's still okay. Then, as mentioned already, we are growing our customer base with a 22% increase in the overall number of customers and 10% organically. And that's maybe also important to mention. Our demand side grew. So, we had issues on the supply side but maintained a 98% retention rate, as I mentioned before. So we have customers that are super happy, that stay, and a company that has a very, let's say, stable customer base. Of course, it's much easier to grow than if you're also losing a lot of customers. So we have a solid base to further grow. Then the integration of June Michel is here. He will present later. We acquired June Group in July last year. Or let's say actually the 1st of August. The team is now integrated. We can see the cost and revenue synergies, and we are now also preparing for the rebranding. The brand is strong and it's stronger if everything is under the brand. Of course it was. It is known to all the agencies that they work with. So this is a process that also takes some time, and it needs to be well prepared. And we are now working on doing the rebranding and finishing it also this year. Sales team expansion. We have a good product. It's B2B. There are over 4,000 agencies in the US. And if you want to sell it, you need to go to those agencies. We have 35 sellers at the moment in the US, with 35 sellers or 35 hunters. So we also have account managers and other people supporting it. But with 35 hunters, you don't have enough people to cover 4,000 agencies. And then we also have the Holdco's, the big agencies, the WPPs, etc. They also have hundreds of thousands of people. So you need to have a bigger staff or a larger number of sellers to really address those. We have started in Q2 with hiring. That's painful because it means a lot of interviews. It also means that if you hire a seller, the seller is not always immediately effective, and you normally don't find out in the first week; it takes about half a year before the seller should really start making money. And by the end of the year, you know it for sure. But that also means that some hires are not good, and you have to redo that. So that's a painful process, but it has to happen. So we want to add 100 sellers or we actually want to reach 150 sellers in the US by the end of next year from the 35 that we have now. Regional adaptation of sales strategy. If you have more people, you can expand regionally. The US is very regional. You need an office in Chicago. You need an office on the West Coast or in San Francisco, in LA, etc. So also there, you're closer to your customers. So that makes life also easier. Segment focus. Another important point, I will cover that a bit later. But you have different industries. Different industries have different experts. And also for advertising, there are differences, and then there's a focus on the capital market. I'll quickly go through, and Christian will cover it in more detail. Our uplisting strengthens, and we are happy to have Ingo on board for bond placement and our capital increase. But Christian will go into more detail. So those are our highlights and challenges. Normally, I put highlights first on the slides and challenges second, but in this case, because of the unification, we put the challenges first and then the highlights second. A bit about the market because there's a lot of talk about the market this week. The market is not weak, etc. What you see here is the price index. And the price index goes with demand and supply. So if it goes down, there is less demand. If it goes up, there's more demand. And what we see here is that advertising development does not follow a straight line. And we have seen different, let's say, downturns. The economy is not performing well. Inflation is going up. Uncertainty is a factor there. I mean there are some mentioned here. Um, what we see now is that it is not going up as fast as we've mostly seen before. But still, as I said before, this is not a reason to not grow. So there are market dynamics at play. Programmatic advertising is growing faster than other parts of the market. We have the ability to further gain market share, and we're doing that. We have a high level of customer satisfaction with a 98% retention rate. We also had a 94.96% retention rate in the past, but we have a very high retention rate. And in technology, we see and further believe that our idealist targeting is really very strong, giving us more market share and more opportunities. What are our growth drivers? Why are we growing? First of all, market growth. Yes, there are hiccups, but there is market growth and acting in a market with tailwinds is, of course, much easier than if the market goes down. Emerging channels. As I started with in the presentation, customer expansion in B2B was mentioned earlier. Add more customers, add more agencies, add more brands, add more publishers, add more verticals, add more geos, and have enough account management and a good product to really scale those customers. Typical B2B differentiation. There are a ton of companies in this market. New products, innovation, idealists. I mentioned that a few times, but there are also new ad formats, including full-screen video ads. Those are partly features that our platforms didn't have. Partly in areas where we truly innovate, providing new formats. Having an SDK. So software integrated in an app gives us the possibility to really show new formats to do things. Audio podcasts are really something we're now focusing on, where we see a lot of potential. A lot of podcasters don't get enough listeners on their podcast, and we help them with that. We help them to generate traffic for that. So that's an interesting market. And then platform synergies, its technology scaling makes sense. The more you scale, the more efficient you get. The bigger you get, the more efficient. That's also the reason for unifying the platforms, because otherwise it doesn't work like that. But also, having more size gives you more data and the possibility to invest more in AI and the combination of AI and data. Paul will especially go into that later, which is super important. That's where you can also differentiate the company. That's where you can gain more, become more efficient, be more relevant. So those are the four growth drivers: market growth, customer expansion, new products, and platform synergies that drive us. What's our strategic rationale for the organization by industry? So we really delve deeper into the industry and I'll cover these points in more detail. Multi-channel approach. We want to be a full customer journey. So yes, we're very strong in in-app, but it makes a lot of sense to also do CTV, digital audio, digital out-of-home, and retail media. We want to follow the customer, the consumer where he is, and also at the right time, show the right ad to get the most effective outcome. And then, as mentioned, it's very important to prioritize privacy and maintain high-quality standards. There's still a lot of fraud in this market created for advertising pages. These pages are designed primarily to attract people merely to display advertisements. A lot of, let's say, bad traffic. I think that's what people don't like. If you are a brand, you want to show your ad in a good environment and prioritize privacy. You don't want to upset the consumer. Also, it's not only that there's less data available, but as an advertiser, as a brand, you want to work with the preferences of a consumer and not go against them. Verticalization. Here are some examples. And the examples are coming back later in the presentation. So one of our segments where we're strong and which we're really strongly focusing on is digital brands. Those can be brands like Apple and various others. But we have Otto here as an example. It's the third-largest German digital retailer, where we showed good results. And if we really understand the segment, we can use our standard tools, tailor them, and bring sector expertise in there. So that makes a lot of sense. CPG is very important and stands for fast-moving consumer goods. CPG is more of a US term. Additionally, they are driving incremental sales, ensuring that people sell their products. Adding to cart, for example, is something that we do in the medical and health sectors. Another example is really making sure that we help Pfizer in this effort to sell their product. Reducing the cost to reach customers, patients and providers. So that's really important. And with size, we have the possibility to specialize. We have the possibility to hire experts for those segments. And if you have the expert, it's easy to communicate with the agency that sometimes lacks the expertise. And it's easier to talk to the customer who comes from that part. So it's very important with scaling our sales force and scaling our team, we have the possibility to go into segments. Channels mobile, I mentioned already before; that's our strongest. Very strong direct supply base. There's a lot of intermediating in this business where there's indirect supply that we have to direct. We are integrated in apps. We have direct integrations to serve the ads. Premium supply. It's very important to ensure you are in a good environment when displaying your ad. So that's what we've been focusing on. And that's the biggest part of our business now. Connected TV, we have a strong position on the supply side. So we already reach 60% of US households with direct CTV. But as mentioned before, we are working on further developing our sales story and refining our USPs in that area. It's still a very fragmented market. And if you look at the other players, nobody really has a competitive advantage. So there's a big opportunity that we see, and we are working on retail media. A lot of our customers are already from the CPG area or CPG part, or even also on the retail side, but we haven't specialized in it much. We are now focused on retail media, which basically means that you want to manage the entire chain. You want to reach the customer outside of the store or in the digital store, but you also want to be able to integrate that into the physical store. More and more stores are getting media in the store, so also making those available. Somebody who normally drinks Pepsi might be targeted by Coca-Cola to encourage them to choose Coca-Cola instead. That's something you can easily accomplish in the store. Digital out-of-home was mentioned before, and there are more and more screens, not only the big ones that you all think about, but also, for example, in Ubers. Now you get into Ubers in the US, you have all the screens that you see with ads. So there's more and more spaces with ads in airports everywhere. They're digital also. That's why it's important to really reach people in the right way. And audio podcasts. Another channel. Very important, growing. Still totally under-monetized. Not a lot of ads yet. And a lot of podcasters, for example, also don't have enough reach on their channels. So there is a lot of opportunity to also enter. Also here, because we are becoming bigger, we have the possibility to specialize in those things to really delve in. But we don't do everything at the same time. We're talking here about our 3 to 5 years and beyond. And these are the channels that we really want to serve. But the opportunities are now, and we need to start working where we really see them. Privacy first quality standards. Indeed, a lot is happening in that area in that respect. Apple introduced AT&T in 2021, which really bans or, let's say, makes targeting much more difficult. No cookies, no IDFA (Identifier for Advertisers) from Apple anymore. Then the IAB met. We have a lot of, let's say, developments happening in the privacy space. But the trend, the tendency is towards more and more privacy, with fewer signals that an advertiser can rely on. So ideally, targeting is becoming standard, and it takes time; we see that with agencies—they are sometimes very slow adopters. You'd rather stick to what you know, you'd rather stick to what you have. But at a certain point, if the targeting is less, you have to change. And we see that happening now. First-party data. We also see that it's becoming increasingly important to be close to the publisher, to be where the data is, or to really build a direct bridge to your consumers, like through loyalty apps, for example. Also, there's a lot of data. First-party data, then AI-powered programmatic optimization. You cannot do this manually. This is all too complex. You need AI to do this. So AI is super important. We're covering that later. And then also, the good thing is, if you do it properly, you have a much better result. People like to see ads that are relevant to them. And what we have is the cookie apocalypse. Also, cookies are not great. If you have a mobile phone and you use it, and the cookie is building a certain profile, and you have a kid that borrows your phone and is doing totally different things, your cookie is totally misrepresenting your behavior. Misused. Misused. Whatever. Sorry, I was looking for the right words. There's a first mover. We have a first-mover advantage in idealist targeting. Idealist targeting is really changing this market, and of course, contextual targeting. You can show an ad, an ad on a car app. That's easy, but then you don't have enough reach. So it's much more complex, as I just showed. So privacy compliance as a competitive advantage is something we're working on, and we will cover that later. Atom, we've talked about it for many years. It's at scale now. We really see the advantage of it. It's helping us. But we have many more things. Solutions on the ideal side. Then strategic roadmap, platform unification for efficiency and scaling. We wanted to really show you what we are doing on that front to go more into detail because it's easy to say, hey, we had issues with platform unification, but we want to go more into detail here. We acquired 16 companies, one-six, to start our ad tech business. Actually, 15 were required in the beginning. And then June Group last year was the 16th. All those companies, almost all of those companies had technology. They all had a team, with 16 teams required along with five supply-side platforms, three demand-side platforms, and five SDKs. SDKs are the ones that are integrated into the apps, with five data lakes and more than five infrastructures. Some had a bit more, some a bit less, but this is what we had to unify. So the target is one team, one supply side platform, one demand side platform, one SDK, one data lake, one infrastructure, and all of those connected to each other and communicating with each other. We have done a lot of that already. So from the five supply side platforms, we were back to two. And we integrated those two big ones. And that's where the majority of our business is in the in-app supply side platform. Here are examples of hiccups that we encountered. A load balancer didn't function well. We do almost a trillion bids per day on that platform. On the combined platform, it's incredibly vast. And that's where things were that we were not able to test at scale before we did the unification. So there was a lot of preparation. For more than a year, our engineers and product team had been preparing for this migration. But there are some things that you cannot test under such a load beforehand. And if you have a hiccup in the platform or if you have an issue in the platform, even if it's a small one on the other side, there's an AI system. So if that AI system's bid is not accepted, or let's say their request is not accepted, it means that it stops and only starts slowly testing at a certain point again. So with all these electronics that we're working with and all the software, there are things that just take longer to ramp up. Again, the issues were more than we expected. They took a bit longer, but the good thing is this in-app unification is done now. We still have to do CTV and web. Those are being prepared, but the volumes are a lot lower. The volumes are a lot lower, and we have seen this before with other platform migrations. We didn't have these kinds of issues. This is a one-time issue and we have solved it. We still have to further develop the SDKs. So you see the, how to say, the accomplished points there. So what's still open on the unification? We still have to further unify our SDKs, which can be done step by step. So that's not one big thing where we have to do everything at the same time. As mentioned, the web and the CTV platform are smaller things where we don't expect issues. The big one was this in-app unification. The good thing now with the unified platform is that we are more efficient. We can further scale it. We can concentrate on building features for one platform instead of for several platforms. So the company is really fit for the future. With this. Coming to the next strategic roadmap point: investment into sales and geographic expansion. I mentioned it already before. Our main market accounts for 97% of our revenues. We have 35 people, hunters who go to agencies to acquire new customers. As mentioned before, that's not enough. We want to reach 150. So the US is our biggest market, and we want to really grow strongly there. But also, we want to internationalize with all the products we have and all the sector expertise. This year we're going into the UK, Scandinavia, Brazil, and Mexico, which means we already had some presence there, but we're really focusing on it now. It means on the supply side and on the demand side, and really building it. And for next year, we want to add a few markets to that. So that will be done in the next few years. We will. Each year, we want to add some markets and, of course, scale the other ones. We have done M&A in the past. The market is consolidating. We see a lot of potential. There are a lot of companies that want to sell. And if you look at the adtech market, there are over 100 SSPs. Over 100 DSPs, over 200 data partners, over 4000 agencies. So it's a very crowded market. Customer demands include companies that offer more channels, essentially functioning as one-stop shops. And as such, there's a natural tendency towards consolidation. Additionally, the ability to scale allows larger companies to invest more in AI and technology, encompassing all necessary aspects. So it makes sense that companies grow. We can grow organically. That's our main focus and to make that very clear. But there might be, and that's the reason we have it here, opportunities to really scale faster, which can involve raising more equity and getting extra sales teams. I mean, June Group is a very nice example of effectively getting a lot of agency relations salespeople on board, which we did, increasing revenues, of course, but also enhancing regional access. Building up a new market is not always easy. So sometimes it makes sense to rather do a small acquisition. We will be very disciplined. I think that's very important to say, because M&A is only an add-on and should be the exception. Then our team strengthened the core team; we are continuously working on getting a better team, making sure that we have a super motivated team, and that we have a very high-performance team. We also made changes in the core team. Christian, CFO, Samir, and Alex were already in, but we added Michele. Shell, Prasanna, and David joined to really get a few more shoulders to carry the business on and to also bring a bit more focus into the teams. Our overall size. So 97% of the revenues are in the US, and 350 out of 850 employees are there. We have quite a large employee base in Europe, and we are building a larger base in Asia. We have a big development center in Bangalore, India. And just as an idea in development, that's a rough number, of course, maybe 300,000 salary per year in the US, 150 K in Europe, and 75 K in India. So we also focus on keeping our personnel costs down, or let's say, efficiently manage them, which is very important. Yeah. Evolving from a publisher to an edtech platform, I showed the slide already before the summary slide. So we're coming a long way and we have a lot of potential for the future. And that's this slide. So we stick to our mid-term guidance of 25 to 30% revenue CAGR. This company can grow. This company is very strongly equipped to grow. I hope that I was able to show that with a strong EBITDA margin, 30 to 35%. Yes, there's some seasonality. And yes, in Q2 we were at 28%, a bit under it, but this company will achieve a 30 to 35% EBITDA and a 20 to 25% EBIT margin. And our net leverage is between 1.5 and 2.5. We are on the higher side now. We want to bring that down. And with more cash flow generation, we will accomplish that. So the target is to reach the next milestone in the future. We want to exceed a billion in revenues. We want to get over 330 million in EBITDA. And the growth should, for the most part, be organic. That brings me to the end of my part, and I would ask Christian to continue with the financial part. Thanks.
Thank you very much, Remco. Good to meet you all here today. My name is Christian Dos, and for those I haven't had the pleasure of meeting before, I joined as CFO on the 1st of January this year. I'll go through the performance of Q2, but before I dig into the numbers, allow me just to summarize what I think has been a very productive first half of the year in terms of capital market transactions or capital market milestones and achievements. Starting in chronological order. You will note that we had a bond refinancing in April. We placed a €500 million bond to refinance our existing bonds, and we did that at, I believe, quite attractive terms in the sense of a three-month Euribor plus a 4% credit margin. That means today, with roughly two percentage points on Euribor plus the 4%, we pay 6% on our bond debt. This is going to lower our cash interest expenses through the year as we move forward with an estimated impact of 12.5 million and will help our free cash flows. It obviously also gives us stability in terms of our financing and our capital structure for the coming years. It's a four-year duration and a significant achievement. Secondly, we upgraded to the general standard in Frankfurt from the scale segment to the regulated part. This is a key achievement we're very proud of, especially also the inclusion in the DAX, which has a lot of benefits both in terms of credibility and awareness in the broader European investor spectrum. So that was a major achievement for the year with a lot of preparation. Um, but with a very successful outcome. And thirdly, we had a directed capital raise here in June. 360 million SEK, €32 million, well-subscribed amongst institutional investors. And this gives us a good structure between debt and equity for the time going forward. Also, to have proceeds to fund growth, whether they be more organic investments or more inorganic investments. So all in all, a very successful and very active first half of the year for me coming on board even with the closing of the 2024 Annual Report. But I'm very happy to be here today. And I can, um, show these milestones. What is not on this slide is that with the addition of Ingo Mittleman, we are expanding by bringing in a very senior person to our investor relations team. Now, I'll move into the actual performance of Q2, just focusing here on the highlights. We grew as a group, achieving a 10% increase in top-line revenue growth compared to last year. This is, however, a mix of developments in that we had a supply side of the business, the SSP part of the business, which declined by 3%. This is because of the technology unification issues. And I'll come back to go more into that. On the other hand, we experienced an 82% growth in our demand side activities. So it's a mix of different things that are going on in the business. And we had a very strong growth contribution from our DSP side. And that also just to clarify means that the revenue challenges we had in Q2 are purely from the SSP side and specifically from the marketplace activities. The performance of the SSP side, and especially the marketplace activities, was obviously not up to our expectations. It's very clear. Uh, and I'll come back to what we look at for the rest of the year. Despite the revenue gap that emerged out of this compared to our expectations, we delivered an adjusted EBITDA, which is marginally higher compared to the same period last year at 29.5 million. And this is, of course, also helped by the consolidation effect of June Group compared to this period last year. We continue to invest, we continue to keep our plans to invest in the platform and in our sales capacity. We already referenced that. And that's also potentially why you don't see a higher lift in our adjusted EBITDA. Good. Let me then dig down a little bit in the business KPIs. And how are our business KPIs developing? There's a lot on that slide. So let me try to break it down and just say overall we continue to grow the adtech business year on year. This is evidenced here in the right-hand corner with a 15% uptick in ad impressions. That's the volume that flows through our systems. It's up 15% versus the same period last year, and also in the total number of customers that you see here on the top line, where we grew by 22%. We actually added 561 customers compared to the same point last year in terms of total number of customers. So the business is growing from that perspective. We, however, also observed that we were handling less budget from our existing customers. You can see that in the net dollar expansion rate here on the bottom corner, which was 92%. That essentially means that we handle 8% less volume from our existing customers. If you compare one year back in time. And the big effect there actually comes from us not being able to scale our customers sufficiently, and also from not onboarding customers due to some of these technical issues that we had. We simply do not want to onboard new customers when the platform is not stable. You make a very bad impression. The silver lining and the positive news is that we did not lose customers. We actually had a client retention rate of 98% for the customers, the software clients that are above 100,000. As you can see here, they spent less. And for the customers that are above 100,000, some of them spent less to the degree where they went under the threshold of 100,000 gross per year, but they didn't leave us. We have a customer retention rate of 98%, which means a 2% churn rate. That's pretty solid even for a tech company by my standards. So net net, we're growing. Our customers used us less in Q2 because of the technical setbacks, but we haven't lost them. It just fell under the threshold of how we define a large software client, which is 100,000 gross. I think the KPIs reflect and pretty much reflect the situation that we've gone through in Q2, and there is nothing surprising on that front. And we do expect the KPIs to improve, with this being a temporary impact on the KPIs. The KPIs will improve through Q3 and Q4. You may then ask me after the session by how much and how quickly, and this is difficult to assess. We have to take into account that we did have a sustained impact into July and just the beginning of August. Um. We expect improvements later in the quarter, but then you also have to weigh it with seasonality, because not every month is the same weight. And therefore, it's actually a difficult question to assess. But I'm confident that we will see an improvement in these business KPIs as we move through the year. That's a little bit about how the business is moving under the motor of the business. If I then go to actual performance and the key highlights of financial performance for Q2, we see that total revenues grew by 10%. As referenced by Remco, it is up from 97 to 106 million. We had organic growth adjusted mainly for acquisitions and also for currency effects, which was -4%. We did face currency headwinds from the euro to the dollar and back to the euro for this quarter. And all those adjustments together mean that our organic growth was -4%. Net net, while our revenues disappointed, we see personnel costs in line with our plan, actually below what we intended to deploy for the year. Um, so those are in check. We did have an effect, and I'll come back to that impact of extra technology costs for Q2. Overall, we achieved a 28% adjusted EBITDA margin, slightly up from the comparable period last year. Um, and we achieved a 21% EBIT margin. When we look at the technology costs that hit us in Q2, it's roughly 4 million. I'll come back to you. That translates into a 3.7 percentage points effect for Q2. And then you can do the math yourself. Still very decent profitability for a company. Um, even for a tech company. And we, of course, expect the operational margin, which was impacted in Q2 by these effects, to improve over the year. Cash flow generation was 5 million. Positive in totality before networking effects, it was actually 15. But then there was a negative effect from cash flow from net working capital. So all in total, it is plus 5 million, again impacted by lower revenues for the quarter. And we continue to invest. We had investments of 9.4 million in total. If I take a step back and put Q2 into the context of a longer time series, just to put it into perspective here, we illustrate this with the LTM (Last Twelve Months) basis of June 2025 on both revenue growth and EBITDA. I think we can see that we continue to track revenue growth and EBITDA growth despite a lower uptick in performance in Q2 than we had anticipated. I think by all means, you can see we have a strong track record of converting investments, both organic and inorganic, into revenue growth and attractive margins. And I see no reason why we cannot overcome this temporary setback for Q2 and prove that again. It might just take a little bit more time, but I think the track record of this company is there and proves it. Moving into operating cash flow and CapEx development. I'll just preface here that now comes a very dense slide, but I'll try to break it up into its different components. If we look at operating cash flow development for us on an LTM basis as of June 2025, you can see the operating cash flow generation in the dark blue bars on the chart. And we moved down. We moved to 115 million, down from 137 million on a full year basis for 2024. This is again because of the effects on the top line in Q2, and therefore it's not following the normal seasonality effect of cash flows across the quarters, as you usually see. Normally, Q1 is our lowest quarter and Q4 is our strongest quarter, and it increases over time. And therefore, we also expect an uplift in cash flow generation for the year as a whole, picking up in Q4 in particular, which is the biggest quarter for this type of business. You will note a first positive effect on cash interest expenses here in gray. We moved from 45 million to 43 million on an LTM basis. And so you see the first effects of lower interest rate costs. And of course, as we move out the LTM number, you will see that the old levels of interest flush out and you achieve the new levels. So it's very positive. We see that we achieved a net of 64 million in free cash flow after interest, which is still at a healthy level. Note when you look at the LTM number, we also had one-off expenses and one-off payouts in Q1 and Q2. We had fees around the bond. We had a prepayment on one earnout. We had several things that also kind of throw off the normal run rate of the business. Moving to CapEx development. We've shown this slide a number of times. If you focus here on the blue and the dark blue, which represent our CapEx investments for maintenance and expansion development. We are at an LTM basis of 35 and eight, respectively. We have communicated that we would end the year with a particular focus. We expect this year to invest somewhere between 40 to 45 million as CapEx. We are tracking closer to the 40 than to the 45 million, but otherwise unchanged views on what this business needs of investments going forward. That was operating cash flow and CapEx development. And I now move to. Net leverage ratio, interest coverage ratio. We largely maintained our ratios into Q2. You see a marginal worsening from 2.4 to 2.5 times net leverage ratio to 2.5 times now on an LTM basis. Again, this is the operating cash flows that affect. On the other hand, you saw a marginal improvement in the interest rate coverage here from 3.3 to 3.4. If you compare again LTM with where we ended the year, this is the positive effect of the interest savings or the reduced levels of interest rates. Deliberation remains a key point for us. A key focus point for us, albeit Q2 probably slowed us a little bit in that regard. Our mid-term target is to achieve a net leverage ratio closer to two times, and I just want to make sure that this remains a focus for us. And it's clearly understood. That kind of concludes my financial part as it concerns Q2 in particular. Now I'll move to guidance, because this is probably also what you've been interested in hearing about. You will have noted, we changed our guidance Thursday, and we lowered and revised our guidance for the full year. Let me try to break down the components and contributing factors here. And just try to break it down into components. I think in the big picture, unification challenges, technical challenges, and the unification account for two-thirds. This is illustrated by the gray area. There was a direct impact during Q2, but also in July and just the first days of trading in August, which altogether, when you calculate it through, amounts to 19 million. We then also had additional costs during that time on two fronts. One, of course, we used all our resources and incurred mitigation costs to address the technical issues. And as Remco was explaining, we also encountered issues with the load balancers, resulting in additional hosting costs amounting to 4 million. So that all relates as one-time effects. And then another thing that has happened is that our expectations, and we can see where we are on the dollar to euro translation, is outside the range that we expected. When we gave the initial guidance, we communicated that we would expect changes in the euro to dollar exchange rate to have an effect of plus or minus two percentage points on the total impact. We see now that we are outside that guidance, and we have revised the planning assumptions to be on a constant currency basis, using a US dollar to euro rate of 0.855. And that altogether would have an impact, when you look at it over a full year, of 9 million. So that's basically the components: two-thirds from the unification challenges, and one-third from translation, pure currency translation effects for the full year. We acknowledge that Q2 fell short of expectations, certainly also our expectations. Uh, trading levels are now stabilized at the same level as the comparable period last year. Um, for the marketplace activities specifically, I'm talking about here, and that makes us confident in a sustained pickup for the remainder of the year. When you pull all that together in numbers. I show here our revised guidance compared to the guidance we gave initially on May 28th. Our new guidance is 485 to 515. That represents a 10% downward revision. At the same time, we're narrowing our guidance by 5 million, respectively, on adjusted EBITDA. We are guiding 125 to 140 million, representing a 20% downward revision of our initial guidance. Um, and also, they are narrowing the guidance by 5 million. We have good confidence in our revised guidance, given the pickup we're seeing in trading and experiencing here in August. We have for roughly four and a half months to go. I remind you that Q4 is the biggest quarter for this type of business. And. So we have some things to do here for the remainder of the year, but we are fully comfortable with this guidance. Important for those that look at currency translation effects. We are giving this guidance on a constant currency basis. Um, we continue to be exposed. We are quite exposed on the top line towards the US dollar, with approximately 89% exposure to it. Um, and therefore, please keep that in mind as we see for the remainder of the year how the US dollar translates into euros. That basically concludes the update on the financial performance background for our revised guidance. And I hope it also provides some insights into what exactly has impacted the business KPIs for this period. And with that, I think I hand back to Ingo.
I'm coming, I'm coming. Thank you so much, Christian, for the color on financials.
You enjoyed it.
I enjoyed it. That's good. I enjoyed it. So you can stay right up here. Uh. Of course. Now it's time for our first Q&A session. Um, how we're going to do this here in the room. If you have a question, please raise your hand so a team member from our team can bring a microphone over. But I think until we have the first microphone transferred to the first question. I'll start with some questions from the online chat. So to sum it up, we still see uncertainty in the market on our release from Thursday night, which is very understandable. The platform unification has caused a share price decline of approximately 22%. Yesterday, we increased by six. This morning, I saw we're up by ten. So we're regaining confidence in the market. But to sum this up and a couple of questions here. Um, Christian and Remco, we highlighted that the effects from the unification will be around 30 to 34 million on revenues and 19 million on EBITDA. And the question we're having here is now, is that really it for the rest of the year? Is everything in Q2 and Q3? Now, in these numbers, and are there going to be any further unification steps in the further course of the year?
Okay, maybe I can take the first part and then you can take the unification part. So yes, the total effects of our expectations for the year are included in this guidance. We have obviously tried to model various scenarios for the year. And the 34 million on top and 19 million are included in those numbers.
And on the integration steps, maybe you could elaborate.
Yeah, I had it in my presentation. So integration is done. That's important. Um, we finished it by the end of July. Of course, the effects are, let's say, a little bit going into August, but we see that we're back on track. Platform runs, numbers are coming up, and onboarding has continued, or let's say, it is starting again. Um, so in that sense, uh, well, in time for the very important, uh, Q4 and also end of Q3, because from basically September onwards, advertising is the strongest, let's say, period, or it's the strongest period for advertising. So happy that we finished this before, even though it took longer.
Okay, maybe I can take the first part and then you can take the unification part. Okay, maybe I can take the first part and then you can take the unification part. So maybe the first question from the room here from the audience.
Okay, maybe I can take the first part, and then you can take the unification part. Okay, maybe I can take the first part and then you can take the unification part. Uh, Vincent Jordan from Pareto Securities. Uh, first off, I would like to ask you a question. Based on the updated guidance, you showcased a bridge here explaining the financial impact of the issues that you faced in Q2 and Q3. But how are you taking into account the softer market that you're also experiencing and mentioning here in the presentation?
Yes. Should I? Yeah. Um, I discussed, or let's say, I showed that the market is a bit softer, at least if you look at the statistics in the market. But as also mentioned, um, we don't see that as a reason not to perform. And yes, a bit of softness is there, but we have a strong product with idealists. We have a strong position in the channels that grow most because those were average numbers for the whole advertising market. So the channels where we are, let's say, are outperforming that part. So it's not a market where we say, hey, wow, we have great tailwinds with everything growing rapidly. That's not the case. But it's also not a reason to see any issues there. Unless, of course. And that's something we don't have a crystal ball to predict. But if something really explodes, uh, I don't know, China goes into Taiwan or something, that's unforeseen. But for the current market conditions, which we expect to remain about the same, we see the possibility to further grow and not be too bothered by the fluctuations of the market.
And can I just add on the 34 million top line effect we consider in a scenario where there is a tail end of how fast those customers that were affected will grow and scale, which is included in the 34 million. So there's still a tail-end effect in that number. Not material, but that's how we try to gauge it for a full year consideration.
So it's not a market where we say, hey, wow, we have great tailwinds from everything is growing like hell. So it's not a market where we say, hey, wow, we have great tailwinds from everything is growing like hell. That's very clear. And also now, we're on August 25th. It's been just shy of a year since you announced the acquisition of June Group. How would you evaluate the performance so far of June Group as being part of the team?
I would almost say, Michelle, come on stage, but he's not wired up with a microphone, so he can say maybe a few words later on. No, we're super happy with the acquisition. There were a few aspects; I'd say a few risk aspects and a lot of positive things. First of all, adding a lot of salespeople, establishing agency relations, and utilizing a lot of tools. Also, the zero party product that Michelle is going to show later. Um, so it was a significant amount of accretion, a lot of synergy between the cases also bring them together. That's what we observe currently. Um, the biggest risk we saw at that time was, let's say, two actually. The first was that the company was not growing. Um, they were milked by the previous owner. So we had to change the mindset. But that was not so difficult actually to get them to grow, to invest, to now also hire sellers, etc. But if something really explodes, uh, I don't know, China goes into Taiwan or something that's not in. Um, and the other one was really the team, a team with a tenure of between 8 and 14 years at least. The core group of 20-30 people has such a long tenure. And I've learned one thing. If it's a tight team and you start changing things, there's of course a risk that the team doesn't like it. And that was where we were really slow in integrating. Executing it with great caution. First, getting people used to each other, then slowly integrating the salespeople that Verve already had into the June sales team. And now, also with, let's say, the change in our top management, in our executive team, we are really focusing on getting product technology and commerce split across the different departments. So we really took time for it, a year, but it went extremely well. And yeah, later Michelle can maybe say a few words about it. Thank you.
Yeah. And then maybe in between until the next person receives the microphone. One question from the chat. Maybe for Remco here. Remco, can you explain, um, like the future of the unified platform? How will we benefit in detail from the unification? And what are the really important drivers from which we are now able to benefit?
More complex answer or easier answer? I mean.
I think we cannot comment on financials. Of course.
No, no, no. I think it's about, how should I say it. The. Yeah. What's the effect of a unified platform? If I have two platforms, I have two teams that need to work on features. I have two platforms where I have to run an infrastructure for, et cetera, et cetera. So two platforms are just much more inefficient than one platform. Integration has the disadvantage that you have those two teams working on each of the platforms. Plus, you need to get extra manpower to prepare the integration, which means that on one of the platforms, you basically build the features that are on the other platform. So you have a phase during the integration where you actually need more manpower than you need for the two platforms. With a unified platform, you free up that manpower. So that's one advantage. But by freeing up the manpower, you can really also work on the platform. You can build new features, and you can really build new things on the platform. So you can really focus on the market and go with that. So what was not so visible? Of course, bringing the platforms together requires extra manpower and incurs additional costs. But also in that period you were very internally focused. Well, if you're one platform, you can really focus externally. You can really build the things that your customers want that bring you further in the market. So there is this double effect. Let's say it's more efficient, but it's also propelling us at a much higher speed for innovation as we move forward. So you have a phase during the integration where you actually need more manpower than you need for the two platforms.
So you have a phase during the integration where you actually need more manpower than you need for the two platforms. So the next question from the audience, please, Rasmus. Yes. Hi.
Hi. Rasmus here with Kepler. I had two questions. Can I first start with the guidance? You had -4% organic growth in Q2. It seems that you expect organic growth to return in the fourth quarter. But what about the third quarter? Is it negative or positive during the latter half of the quarter? Or how should we think about that in your guidance?
Sure.
I can, I can also, yeah.
I think, uh, so obviously Q3 will be a mix. Uh, we have said that July is impacted on the first day of trading for this part of the business. Right. Just to remind you, the 4% organic growth is for the combined group. But if we talk about the market activities, there was some impact in July during the first days of trading, and we are stable now but not quite on the growth path. So Q3 will be a mix. Uh, Q4, uh, we expect strong organic growth for sure. That's what I can say at this point. Obviously, we run a number of scenarios on both the top line and bottom line, and we try to pull that into what we think is a good reference point and reference range.
No, I think you described it perfectly well.
And the second question, obviously, it's probably a question for your more technical people, but have you achieved what you wanted to achieve in terms of efficiency savings with the integration? So, is it fully up and running as you wanted it to be?
Yes and no. We achieved what we wanted. It's a platform unification, but it took longer. As I've shown on the slide, there are still some smaller things left to address. So that's not ready yet. And you, of course, are never ready. That's the end of the section. No. So the yes is. We have achieved it. The no is you're never really ready with these kinds of things. So we will work on further efficiency. I mean, I will get it later. It will bring extra efficiency in. It will bring benefits to the platform as well as the team. And yeah, the question is, how does the company of the future look? How many people do you need to run a company? Those things. So there are always efficiency gains to come. So you're never completely ready in that aspect. A company that remains at a standstill is going to die. So you need to innovate. You need to grow. You need to implement AI to become more efficient. So I hope that answers your question. But it's a difficult one to answer because it's a process and not a final thing.
Thank you. Yes. Please continue.
Yes. Good morning. Uh, Alice Acland with First Berlin. Thanks for the detailed presentation so far this morning. Um, two questions from my side: I'd like to touch on your current M&A posture. Uh, it sounds like you're becoming a bit more open-minded about that at this moment. And then also, just to tie in what you were talking about with unification, now that you have everything on a clean, single platform, if you go and make another big deal, are you going to have to also integrate that? So is that going to restart in some form or fashion?
The company is a process. And thanks for the question. First of all. Alice. Um, yes, we have an M&A slide in there. We also had some discussion about whether to include it because, on one hand, the market is consolidating. So there are opportunities in the market, and we need to grow and we need to grow faster to get bigger. So in that sense, there is rationale. But as I said already, M&A needs to be handled with utmost care. We don't need it. We are a strong organic growth company. So in that sense, M&A is a luxury, which basically solves things where the organic way of doing it would take much longer. And the point that you make, of course, is if you buy another platform, another technical platform, then you have to do another technical integration. So before we buy a company that has another technical platform with a lot of integration concerns, we'll think four times, five times, six times about it before we would do something like that. So I see M&A more in really acqui-hire kind of directions instead of focusing on really big technical platforms or things.
Okay.
That's maybe, maybe an add-on from my side. Let's not forget that this unification represented around 90% of our revenues. So if we integrate further on the CTV side now, this is still ahead of us. But that's a way smaller revenue share and, therefore, the effects will hardly be seen because you might have a hiccup of 5 to 8% or something. Again, based on these revenues that this platform stands for. And in this case, that was the majority of the whole company.
Yeah, that's the point. I mean, it's a good point you're making. This migration was huge. And I mean, we have done a lot of migrations before that were not noticed, or let's say, we didn't see the effects, but this one was really big and in that sense, very exceptional.
Okay. And the point that you make, of course, if you buy another platform, another technical platform, then you have to do another technical integration. That was very helpful. Um, and then just a short one, uh, you mentioned that you didn't lose any of your existing customers during the unification process. Um, that was mainly about onboarding new customers. How did that impact you? Did you lose any potential new customers because they needed to conduct their business immediately and couldn't wait for you to finish your unifications?
Yeah, thanks for the question. First of all, it's not that we didn't lose customers. We had a 98% retention rate. That means that we lost some customers. Some customers were lost, but not many. You always lose customers as a company. So I think that's important to just put that right. However, we indeed had to delay the onboarding of customers. But as far as I'm aware, they're all patient and waiting. Um, and we didn't lose any of that. And everybody in this market is not dependent on one intermediary. So you have several. So it's not a problem to wait. The only problem that we might have had, and I don't think we have it, is if you run towards Q4 and people then further postpone an integration, because nobody wants to do any technical work in Q4, as that's your main quarter. That's where you make most revenues, and you don't want to have any risk of disrupting your Q4 with technical work. So in that sense, I'm happy that we are now in the process of integrating well before Q4.
Okay, guys, thank you very much.
Great. Then maybe in between, one question from the chat. It's on Euro-dollar translation inflation effects. How are we going to handle this in the future? Are we going to do hedging and what are our strategies regarding this topic?
And everybody in this market is not dependent on one intermediary. So let's just put it in perspective. Obviously, we are now in an environment and have been for, let's say, the last year where the euro to dollar translation has experienced much more volatility. If you look back in time, it's just a different market environment and more volatile in such a case. And everybody in this market is not dependent on one intermediary. Then you consider whether you should do hedging. We are exposed on our top line in particular with roughly 89% of our revenues, which are registered in US dollars. We also have quite a bit of our cost base, but not to that degree in US dollars. So there's a natural hedge from our cost base that, I would say, mitigates or offsets, which is probably the right word. Some of the impact on the top line. We are evaluating the situation of hedging to do it properly. Uh, there are a number of elements where you need to have a quite advanced Treasury setup to manage it on an ongoing basis. Uh, otherwise you go into somewhat large bulk positions, and you're essentially also taking a bit of a bet on where the market is going. So we are looking at what is a good level of hedging for our type of business, considering the complexity and the exposure we have. But I also want to make sure that we have the right hedging strategy and also set up to handle it on an ongoing basis. It's not quite as easy as people might think it is and just doing one forward contract.
And everybody in this market is not dependent on one intermediary. And everybody in this market is not dependent on one intermediary. And maybe, if I may add to that, I think what's very important is currency fluctuations are a very normal thing if you have to shift currencies between euro and dollar. And they will stay. So it's not important that you eliminate all of these effects, but that you manage market expectations properly. And that's why we decided, for the further course of the year and the years ahead, to publish our currency ratio or our exchange rate that we calculated our guidance with. So in this case, I think it was 0.855. And maybe, if I may add to that, I think what's very important is currency fluctuations are a very normal thing if you have to shift currencies between euro and dollar. Was it right?
That's right.
So for that point, it means all investors know what we calculated with; if dollars go up or dollars go down, you can calculate yourself what the effect will be. Sometimes we're going to have a plus. Then we don't want the benefit on our side. But sometimes we're going to lose something. So we'll see how far we're going to develop into hedging in the future. But I think that it is the most important thing that you, as our investors and analysts, know what to expect. So please, Jörg.
Philip Fry, Warburg. Well, you had a nice chart regarding the softness of the market. Some price declines of CPMs, uh, in your presentation. And, uh, in the second quarter, we also saw that the walled gardens had very decent pricing. Meta. For example, at plus nine. How do you look at this? First of all, a bit of a comment on the difference in pricing regarding the open internet and the walled gardens. And do you expect this positive pricing of walled gardens to be more of a leading indicator of what is to come for you, or more or less some gap closing, or what's your view on that one?
Yeah. Thanks for the question, Philip. The walled gardens are, of course, something special. We showed before the percentages of margin that the technology takes. And what goes to the publisher. The advantage is. And that's what the walled garden has. If you are the publisher yourself and you have the technology, you have a much broader reach and more possibilities for optimizing your margin to take. Now, Google, for example, is under pressure from the Department of Justice to be split up, and they're especially under pressure because they are unfairly playing the open market. So if you were Google, what would you be doing? You say, I'm putting everything on my own supply, which is basically YouTube. So you see a tendency for Google to take market revenues out of the open market. And some of our peers are really hit strongly by that. They take market, let's say, volumes out of the open market. And they don't put them, or let's say, they don't put them on external inventory anymore, but they place them on their own. YouTube. YouTube has become super full with ads if you look at it, and something similar is happening with other platforms. We also see this with other walled gardens where they put more and more on their own properties. There's also quite some criticism on that from advertisers because, um, how really well can you measure? I mean, they also deliver their own measuring capabilities. So at the moment, I would say in the short term, we see a bit of winning on the walled garden side. But talking to agencies and others, um, not everybody is that happy with it. So let's see how it develops in the next quarters. But, um, yeah, especially Google is extremely strong in bringing things in-house at the moment. And that's also what you see in the guidances or, let's say, in the numbers; the Q2 reports show that most walled gardens have done pretty well. The big ones, if you look at the smaller ones, Snap, etc., it's the other way around. it's the other way around.
Very helpful. One additional question on, uh, you mentioned your targets regarding the expansion of your sales teams. Um, how quickly do you expect these to ramp? Uh, how much time for profitability? Or should we expect some margin dilution until these guys, uh, well, hit the ground.
Yeah, it will be a continuous process. Thanks for the question again, Philip. Philip. It will be a continuous process. Of course. You cannot hire immediately. Uh, 50 people at one go. So we had to prepare for that. Um, which means we have sales enablement people, so people that can really build up sales teams. We hired those first. We increased our, um, how to say, internal hiring capacity. So on the HR team, uh, those things had to get in place. Now, there's a lot of interviewing happening. Uh, I just had my meeting yesterday with Michelle, and we signed up six people to start in the next 2 or 3 weeks. Um, the good thing in the US is if you hire people, they are available very quickly. Um, sometimes they still have a commission that they're waiting for, so it might delay a bit if they have done a very strong Q3. Uh, the second month into the next quarter because they don't want to lose their commission on that. But it's a pretty fast process. Normally, you can hire somebody within 2 or 3 weeks, sometimes with a little bit of delay. So we had to first really enable the organization to hire those people, so that when they come in, we can train them properly and really. Yeah, make them productive. Uh, we had to split up the teams a bit. So the team structure was changed a bit. And, um, Michelle is nodding in the back, so I haven't said anything wrong so far. Um, but it's a process. Um, but it's a hefty target, of course, to get from 35 to 150. That's a heavy target. And we're working on it. And if it's 140, I would not be unhappy if it's 155. Also, not. But what we cannot fully estimate is that we hire sellers and not all of them will be good. And the question is, will you have to replace 20% of them afterwards, or is it 40%? And with respect to the cost, we internally calculate that the seller really starts earning back their own salary at the earliest after six months. Um, latest after 12 months. Otherwise, it has to be replaced. So yes, it will put a bit of pressure. And it did already in Q2. Uh, it put a bit of pressure on our EBITDA, but that's okay. Yeah. How do you say investment in the future and you don't capitalize those costs? Uh, it's just cost. But I think it's super important for us as a company to do that and to further grow.
Thank you very much.
And could I just add to that, um, uh, we have the main interviewer in the room today, of course, Miguel. Uh, of course, from a CFO perspective, what is really important is to make sure that we really set high standards for the people we take on board, and not rush to get people on board. And I don't think I've yet experienced in my career a tougher interviewer than Michelle, who upholds higher standards. So from a CFO perspective, I think it's a process, as you say. It's also a balance. We move fast forward, but we also need to ensure we have the right quality of people because mistakes with people are often costly. And that's the balance we need to keep.
Otherwise, it has to be replaced. Thank you, Christian. Next question is over here.
Yeah. Thank you. Nicola from Alexander Collier. So just one question on your big cash position. You're sitting on something like €160 million in cash after raising some €32 million in equity. That's a big, big war chest. What do you want to do with that war chest?
Well, first of all, let me just remind you that we do have certain deferred payments to handle, particularly with June Group. I believe it's $22.5 million in the first installment and then €25 million. Or I have to say, I can't remember if it's euros or dollars on the last payment, and this is coming up within the next 12 months. So already there you have some payouts. Um, we have payouts for the earnout for DataSeat. So some of that ensures that we can pay that. And we want to continue the investments that we are doing organically. And then we, of course, also want to have a good cushion as we move through this somewhat more volatile period than we expected this year to be. At the same time, we have the opportunity to act if we come across something that is really the right fit, like a small addition, then we have the flexibility to act on that, per your comments. But it also explains a little bit the order of priority seen from the CFO perspective in the way that I described it here.
Yeah. Wonderful. Yeah. Thanks for that insight. And just on the guidance downgrade, maybe provide some additional nuance on that one. Um, when would you say that you saw the necessity to downgrade the guidance? Uh, did you see any risk of that sometime mid to late June, or did you see it perhaps during Q3? Now, how would you characterize that?
I think, uh, where we really saw it was in the later weeks of July and our expectations for June. So we could see that we probably have some impacts in July, but it was not recovering at the pace we expected it to. And then also initially in August. Now, of course, I'm talking about one part of the company, which is specifically the marketplace activities. Then you have many other things to factor in. And then when you start calculating on that type of thing, you can see that we would be looking at a changed view. And I think also, as I illustrated, when you then factor in the conversion effect, which is a major part of it as well. And combine that, then you see the perspective of the whole thing.
Yeah. Very helpful.
Um, we have payouts for, um, the earnout for DataSeat. Maybe, maybe also from our side here, it was really the case that Christian approached us on Thursday morning to say that now all hope is gone to recover that in the course of the remainder of the year.
Not all hope.
Not all hope is lost. You're right about that.
The probabilities, then.
The probability is very small that we can recover that. And then, of course, the whole process was started and we decided, let's move forward with the numbers as well. So the market knows what's happening. Um, so that was really the point when the final decision was made.
But those things are not easy decisions. And the problem here is, of course, that first of all, the year gets shorter. So the longer something like the unification issue lasts, the shorter the time you have to recover is. And on the other hand, the more revenue you lose in the time in between. So it wasn't really. Yeah. We had a hefty discussion internally. Um, and of course we will do everything to maximize what we can achieve from this company to really grow. But at a certain point, you have to say and realize that, yeah, it's difficult to really make up. And what we also had to take into account is that we could also have not raised the guidance, for example. But then you get everybody here in this room and online, and many other people all speculating, hey, the numbers are so weak in Q2, we think they have to take the guidance down. That is worse. So it was really a decision that we had to take. And um, yeah, it hurts. But also here we want to be as open as we can be. Um, and to also give the background and the reasons. And I'm happy, really happy that it's not like, hey, it's a terrible market. And that's why we're losing. And we don't know when this is recovering, but let's say, predominantly, it's really an internal thing. And that's over.
And then as an added dimension, you always look at the trading every day and try to evaluate what is the signal of that trading for the remainder of the year, which is very, very difficult. So we followed it closely and came to that conclusion when we pulled everything together. Probability is very small that we can recover that.
Thank you. So looking at the time telling me zero seconds left. Meaning thank you all for participating in the Q&A. Also, thanks to everybody online who participated in this. Really good questions here. Now let's revisit the agenda. Um, it looks like half the fun is over for the day. Part one is behind us. We're now approaching the lunch break. And after that, we're going to have a really interesting tech session with the keynote I'm really looking forward to. And, uh, to executives, uh, following in on, uh, the hottest topic of the industry. So, um, we'll all meet back here at 12:45. And also for those of you online. German? Also, thanks to everybody online who participated in this. So, um, enjoy your lunch. Lunch, please. And I'm looking forward to seeing you back in about an hour. By lunch, good food, and now energized for part two of our Capital Markets Day. It's the Capital Markets Day of Workgroup 2025. We're now kicking it off with the part. I was really waiting for the keynote speech by Eric Seufert, a well-known expert in the digital advertising industry. Eric is a media strategist, a quantitative marketer, an author, and investor who has spent his career working for transformative consumer technology and media companies, including Skype and Rovio, the developer of Angry Birds. He's also the founder of Agamemnon, a startup that built a mobile marketing analytics platform, which was acquired in 2017. He then launched Herakles Capital, an early-stage venture capital fund focused on the mobile ecosystem. Eric, it's really a pleasure having you here today with us. And thank you so much for traveling all the way from the US. Everybody, a big applause, please, for Eric Seufert.
Hey, good afternoon everyone. Um, so thank you for that very generous introduction. And thank you for having me. It's fantastic to be in Stockholm at this time of year. Uh, thanks for organizing this in the summer, not the winter. Um, and I'm really happy to be here. And I'm really happy to be discussing one of my favorite topics, which is what I believe is the total transformation of digital advertising through AI enablement. And, um, I've spoken about this on the blog, uh, in my podcast, and developed a sort of catchall description of how I see this transformation unfolding, which I call 'commerce at the limit.' So this is the agenda for the presentation. I'll kind of start, you know, with an overview of what I believe is at stake with this. I'll move into where we are with a status check on the application of AI to digital advertising. And then I'll kind of talk through where I believe we're headed with this. A little bit about me. Um, before we dive into the content, um, I run a blog called Mobile Dev Memo. It's a trade blog sort of dedicated to what I call the digital economy. So digital advertising, distribution, and merchandising. I am the author of Theseus, which is an open-source Python library for marketing cohort analysis. And I run Herakles Capital, which is an early-stage venture fund devoted to the mobile economy. And prior to doing those things, I worked for a number of companies that you might recognize, especially those of you that are Europe-based. I started my career at Skype as an analyst. I was head of marketing at a company called Wooga, which makes casual games. It was acquired by Playtika. I was a VP of User Acquisition and Network Engagement at Rovio, which makes the Angry Birds franchise. And then my startup was acquired by a company called Network, which was later acquired by a crypto platform. So what's at stake? I think if you follow any companies in the digital advertising space, which you know, by definition, you all do, you're familiar with the application of AI to digital advertising and how it's unlocking a lot of value now, right? And I say that now because Mark Zuckerberg says it's happening now. And, uh, and I think a lot of people look at the application of AI to digital ads as kind of like this far-off opportunity, right. Something that maybe will materialize. And it's a risk, right. But if you look at the way the largest platforms are applying it, it's actually happening right now and it's delivering real value right now. And so this is a quote from Mark Zuckerberg. On Stratechery, fun fact, I was the guest before Mark. But he said, and I'll quote it, I'll read it. And it's kind of awkward, but I think it's a powerful quote. But in general, we're going to get to a point where you're a business, you come to us, you tell us what your objective is, you connect to your bank account. You don't need any creativity. You don't need any demographic targeting. You don't need any measurement except to be able to read the results that we provide. I think that's going to be huge. I think it is a redefinition of the category of advertising. Right. And I think when people heard that, there was, um, this sort of pulse of fear, right? I mean, that sounds like it's just going to displace a lot of people, right? That's maybe going to put a lot of agencies out of business, or it's going to lead to layoffs in marketing teams. But I think there's a flip side, and some of that might be true. Right. But I think there's a flip side to this, which is that it's going to enable essentially anybody to become an advertiser. It's going to enable anybody to participate in the advertising economy. And so when you think about the largest platforms, you know, you think about them onboarding any sort of mom-and-pop shop as an advertiser. But if you think about sort of the entire ecosystem of advertising platforms, everyone can benefit from that, right? And everyone can benefit in unique and idiosyncratic ways that might not be available to the largest platforms. And so, I think for any company operating in the space, there is a sort of looming threat of dislocation just because any new big wave of innovation unleashes that. But I think when I think about the application of AI to advertising, I'm overwhelmed by its potential benefits. I'm sort of overwhelmed by all the positives. And I do believe that those benefits don't explicitly and specifically accrue to the largest platforms. They will accrue to anybody that sort of finds a way to apply them to their business. And digital advertising is just a massive space, and it's a great space. Just, you know, given the nature of the ecosystem, it's a great space for this to be one of the entry points for the application of AI commercially. Right. So Dentsu expects the digital advertising market to reach 678 billion in 2025. That's almost 70% of total ad spend. Digital ad spend will grow by 8%, which is faster than the broader advertising spend growth rate of 5%. And a meaningful proportion of this growth will be delivered by channels that don't adhere to traditional measurement methodologies. So what do I mean by that? Like I've got this catchphrase. You may have heard it. Everything is an ad network, right? And the idea behind everything as an ad network is that after Apple's App Tracking Transparency policy change, there was a massive proliferation of new ad channels emerging because when you revoked that sort of identity spline provided by the mobile ad ID that Apple called the IDFA. When you revoked that, then any channel, any property with unique proprietary first-party data could spin up an ads business and use that first-party data for targeting in a way that wasn't really viable prior to the revocation of the IDFA, because Facebook just owned everything. They were the central store of data for the entire internet. And so when these platforms that previously wouldn't have dared to compete with Facebook had the opportunity to monetize this first-party data set because there was nothing else to really target against, then they decided, hey, I've got this asset. Let me just monetize it by launching an ad network. And so everything became an ad network. But a lot of the 'everything is an ad network' phenomenon is a result of channels that are not click-based building ad systems, or even if they are click-based, they don't integrate well with other sets of data. Right? So thinking about CTV, right? CTV is not measured by traditional measurement methodologies. You can't do last click. You can't do last click attribution; you have to kind of focus on probabilistic attribution and multi-touch attribution. Consider that many retail media cannot be measured with traditional measurement methodologies. And so as these AI methodologies emerge to handle that, you unlock a lot more value that SMS, for instance, couldn't access because they couldn't measure it. And so measurement has become more challenging as the ecosystem grows more complex. So platform policy restrictions — I just mentioned Apple, but there are others. Apple is traditionally more aggressive in this space. You know, as you're all, I'm sure, aware, Google was going to deprecate cookies. Now, they're not. Um, we'll see where that lands. Um, we've got the everything is an ad network phenomenon, which, again, a lot of these new channels are not attributable with clicks, right. CTV Retail media. And then you've got end-to-end automation. Right. So when you have end-to-end automation, that kind of crowds out a lot of the traditional measurement, which was just a function of transparency. So end-to-end measurement platforms are making all the decisions on your behalf. Well, you don't have the ability to impact those decisions. Right. With, for instance, targeting the right placements. Um, but they gain by sort of not making many of those decisions even available to you ex post. Right. And so there's just a level of opacity that precludes traditional, legacy-style attribution. And ultimately, I will address all aspects of advertising value. It's not just measurement, it's not just targeting. Like a lot of people probably think when you say AI and digital advertising, the first place your mind might go is to all of these tools that the largest platforms have introduced, and I'll list them later. They're all kind of named along the same convention. Um, but the reality is it's going to touch every piece of the value chain, right. So you've got measurement and attribution like I just talked about, but you've also got product personalization and monetization, right. So if you sort of remove the levers of, um, of, of targeting, of, of even creative production, from the advertiser, then all they're really left with is this sort of amorphous blob of traffic to their property. All they're really left with to drive performance is what they can send to the ad platform to indicate whether that was good or bad traffic. Right. And so like, this is kind of this emerging topic called signal engineering. Right. So, I'm experimenting with the onboarding session in an app or the registration flow in a certain e-commerce website. And I'm trying to figure out ways to surface. Intent surface. A signal of intent from that user. Traditionally, the way this has been done is by just looking at what's instrumented on the page or in the app and sending all of that to the ad platform. But now, if that's the only lever that I have, I have to actually be much more proactive in determining what is a signal that this person will become a high-value user, and that's signal engineering. And an example of this, which I found really interesting, was when I was on a podcast recently called Marketing Operator, and we were talking about signal engineering. And after that podcast, one of the people on the podcast is the CMO of a large e-commerce brand. And so he wrote on Twitter that as a result of that conversation, he got the gears working in his head about how they could implement signal engineering into their. It's like a beauty shop, right? And so how could they integrate signal engineering into the registration process for this ecom brand. And so they built a CAPTCHA. That was a math problem that didn't gate access to the site as a normal Captcha would. It wasn't really trying to determine whether this person was a bot or not; it was just creating an obstacle for that person to get into the shopping experience. Because if a person is going to go through the trouble of answering this math problem, they're probably quite interested in your products, and they likely have a higher propensity to buy than someone who won't answer the math problem, or who wouldn't answer the math problem if presented with it. And so what they did with that is they just sent that back. The person completed the math problem and sent it back to the platform. And then the platform knew, okay, this is a high-value user. Now, obviously, this would be tested. There may be no correlation between propensity to buy and doing that. But if there is, you have to experiment with these things and design them specifically and proactively to determine intent. Right. And so that's this kind of emerging field of signal engineering. And it's really powerful. And that is left to advertisers currently. But there are numerous ways that ad channels could facilitate that. Right. And you can imagine that there are advantages for smaller ad channels relative to the largest. Right. Because I might not trust one of the largest ad channels to do that in a way that benefits me, but a smaller channel I might trust. And so, to my point from earlier, there are idiosyncratic ways for, I call it AI or just any of these tactics, to be deployed that generate value for platforms outside of, you know, the biggest. Then there's campaign optimization, which I think is kind of like the canonical way that AI is applied to digital advertising. Now, those are things like, you know, PMAX on Google's Advantage Plus, and there's a whole list of them. Um, and the real value of doing that is, A, you tend to maximize advertiser spend when you take control of all optimization levers. Right. So the goal of these systems is not necessarily to, not necessarily to maximize ROAS for the advertiser. It's actually to maximize spend while adhering to some performance target. Right. Um, B you get to make decisions faster. So you really do sort of optimize faster than a human being could, which again maximizes spend. Um, but I think one of the other things is that these systems can be improved incrementally over time. And the really fascinating thing about the digital economy, specifically digital advertising, is that smart advertisers approach digital advertising with a kind of ROAS mindset. If you unlock 5%, say 6% incremental Roas, all of that gets reinvested, right? We were talking last night at dinner about the opportunities with Apple being forced to open up the iOS ecosystem to allow link out, but also alternative in-app payments. And the reality is, you know, there is value in just sidestepping the commission, but there's a lot more value in just bringing a sort of modern approach to the app storefront. Right. And if you think about the App Store as a storefront and you compare it to Shopify, for instance, it looks like it comes out of the Stone Age. I mean, it's not fit for purpose. It's not a modern storefront, you know, relative to what Shopify can do with personalized pricing, dynamic bundling, even just A/B testing based on different demographic features. The App Store can't do any of that. And so you just promote commerce by having these sorts of modern tools there. And so, you know, when you unlock 5%, 6% incremental ROAS, then that just gets reinvested back into marketing. And so, who wins from that? It's the ad channels. I mean, it's the advertisers too, because they're driving higher top-line revenue, but it's the ad channels; they're going to absorb more of that. And then creative production, creative production is really kind of the tip of the spear, I think in a lot of ways, and I'll get into this a little bit later. But creative production, I think, is just more visible as an application of AI. And so people sort of instantly invoke that when they think about applying AI to digital advertising, but the way creative production is done now through AI tools is mostly a cost-saving exercise. It's not really generating a lot of value. The way that you generate value with creative production, to my mind, is actually doing more rigorous hypothesis testing and figuring out what kind of concepts work the best, and using historical data to inform that. And I think I will unlock a lot of value there. So again, I think AI will influence the totality of the customer relationship that any advertiser has. So it's obviously customer acquisition. And that's everything I just talked about. So that's where, how, and with what messaging customers are reached. Also, customer onboarding involves signal engineering to get them into the product correctly, ensuring they are primed to be successful with your product. Right. Better instructions, better, you know, just more personalization. Um, linking what they see in the product in their first product experience with what they saw in the ad. These things can be facilitated with AI to create a more productive customer journey, which probably leads to higher rates of monetization. Then there's customer activation. So the specific moments that are chosen to surface monetization opportunities to customers, right. So do I show an offer early in the customer's first session or do I wait? Do I let them interact with the product more before I try to monetize them? Right. Or do I show an ad at some point in a game, like any specific point when it's most effective? What's the best moment for showing the ad? Um, Paul is going to talk a little bit later about a lot of their on-device technology that surfaces these signals to unlock more precise monetization opportunities, but all that kind of stuff. I mean, when we talk about AI, we're really talking about just, like, high-dimensional machine learning, right? So just machine learning that can make sense, can parse relationships out of high-dimensional data. And so all of that is an opportunity regarding customer retention and merchandising. So, the content and opportunities that are presented to the user keep them engaged with the product. Right. And this really just kind of like elongates the retention curve. So who can win? And I've kind of touched on this already. But the largest platforms have natural data and R&D advantages in developing and deploying AI tools. But they face concrete limitations. Right. So, inventory. So advertisers want to reach audiences on CTV. Retail media and elsewhere. It's not just social media, right. Diversification. So, a lot of SMBs are not really sensitive to any sort of concentration. They can be fully concentrated, but some won't. Right. Just for the sake that they don't want to introduce that risk into their business. What we saw in the Google DOJ suit was that there were customers who allowed for lower price floors on non-Google channels, for no other publishers, for no other reason than they didn't want to be totally reliant on Google. Right? Now, you might say that that's not a rational choice. They should accept the highest bid from whoever's providing it, but for them, it was because they felt that if they were totally concentrated just on Google, they would face business risks that they wouldn't otherwise if they had more diverse demand. Um, and then on-site use cases. Right. So the influence of large platforms doesn't extend into the product experience. I talked about that before. Maybe there are trust issues, right? And so there are other channels that could offer a better ability to influence what happens in the product experience, where that publisher wouldn't trust the same kind of intervention from a larger platform. And that could be for a number of reasons, right? It could be that the platform might not have their best interests at heart. It could be that they don't want to expose that data to the platform because it might be used to benefit their direct competitors. There are numerous reasons for that, right? Those are totally rational. So the influence of large platforms doesn't extend into the product experience. So now I kind of want to go through where we are at the moment. So how is AI being used currently? So there are two use cases that are mostly trapped inside the walled gardens currently. So the first is creative production. So if you think about using generative AI tools to create ad creative, that's mostly a big platform phenomenon. Right now, there are a number of SaaS tools that have emerged to try to handle this. The problem with that use case is it's a loss leader. Like it doesn't really make any money. There's no value. There's no sort of ability to monetize that if you're just a third-party SaaS tool, right? The way you monetize that is you pair it with the data that you have to drive better outcomes if you're a large platform, right. So Meta announced in Q2, in its most recent earnings, that it has 2 million advertisers using its generative AI tools. That's a lot, right? And there's just a natural advantage there because they have 10 million. So getting to scale up to 2 million is, um, they're able to do that fairly quickly. And then the second is campaign optimization. So these are tools like Advantage Plus, Performance Max, Google's Max Smart Plus, TikTok's Performance Plus, and Amazon's Performance Plus. And then Pinterest has one. Um, these allow advertisers to optimize campaigns automatically. It's an obvious use case. Again, there's a tension there because I think it's fairly obvious. It's fairly self-evident that the motivation for this is to maximize spend. It's not really intended to provide the best possible outcome for the advertiser. It's to maximize spend against some performance threshold. But there are other opportunities beyond that for other channels to embrace AI. And these are totally up for grabs as far as I'm concerned. So the first is targeting. So yeah, Advantage Plus manages targeting on Facebook. What about everything off of Facebook? Right. And particularly the channels that I referenced earlier, right. Retail media and CTV, where Facebook has no presence. Google. Google has a large presence through YouTube. But the largest channels are not necessarily operating there. And they're not, and there's no reason why they ever will. Right. So targeting consumers outside of the walled gardens is a really important use case for these tools. The second is measurement. So advertisers want unbiased measurement that accommodates their entire channel portfolio. Right. So it's great if a large platform has measurement baked in. But if I'm running on other channels, that singular focus on that platform doesn't help me. I need measurement that accommodates everything. And then, creative. Right. So creative production, again, is mostly viewed as a cost reduction exercise. But other use cases can be tailored to channel-specific contexts. Right. So, CTV and retail media need tools to accommodate the exhaustive testing that large platforms have built natively. And so, you know, there's an obvious opportunity there for someone to solve that problem. So none of this is superficial and none of this is temporary. I mean, this is a very significant tectonic shift. So direct response marketing teams are embracing the overhaul of the media buying process with open arms. Right. So if you go back to that quote that I opened with, you know, there was opposition to that idea by brands. And, you know, a point that I made was that, well, you're about five years too late, right? Because this is not some new thing. This has been happening for a number of years. Um, and, uh, and, you know, brands and agencies, um, and if you talk to any sort of SMB digital advertiser, don't have to be a small company, but just a company that operates in a lean way. They are, their hair is on fire for this. They want more of it. They want it now. They want more AI enablement because that helps them do more with less. And if you talk about the sort of entrepreneurs or just very small businesses that are excluded from the advertising economy now, I mean, they probably don't know that they don't know this, but they'll be very pleased to have the opportunity to advertise their businesses as a result of these tools. Right. So I think the opposition is a little bit misguided. Now I understand it because, again, it's a dislocation. But this is just expansionary, right. This will bring more people into the advertising economy. So while this starts at the top of the funnel, it will only be enhanced by bottom-of-the-funnel improvements. So then I'm talking about better personalization. Um, to improve monetization. That's kind of on-site stuff. And then better signal construction to improve optimization and targeting. And again, targeting needs to apply to every channel outside of the walled gardens too. And a lot of the growth is happening outside of the walled gardens. So ultimately every ad channel can benefit from these capabilities, and advertisers will expect every channel to offer them. And I think that's an important point. It's not just that, um, this adds value to the sort of customer experience that the advertiser has. Advertisers will choose the ad platforms they work with based on these capabilities, and they're going to expect it from everyone. And AI-enabled advertising is already delivering considerable commercial value. So I won't read the quote again. But in the most recent earnings, I mean, Mark Zuckerberg attributed all the growth. I mean, disproportionately he said the growth was a function of these investments in AI, and these weren't big eye-popping numbers. I mean, he went through each of the three big AI initiatives. You've got Lattice, GEM, and Andromeda, and he talked about a 4% increase in click-through rate or a 5% increase in ROAS, right. These are not 30% or 50% boosts. But again, as the nature of digital advertising, those improvements compound over time and they result in more ad spend coming back to the platform. And then just a few thoughts about where we're headed. And just by the way, as a sort of logistical note. I think we're doing a Q&A on all three of the sessions at the end, so there's no Q&A after this one, but we'll have one big Q&A. So, um, I think it ultimately delivers what I've called commerce at the limit. And so I did a sort of monologue podcast about this a few weeks ago, and I defined commerce at the limit as the fulfillment of complete optimization across every component of the digital advertising process, such that commercial performance attains its theoretical maximum. Right. And if you think about that. So basically every ad is, let's call it, utterly optimized, right. In terms of targeting, in terms of, uh, you know, intense creative pairing, in terms of the placement in terms of the sequence when the person is seeing the ad. Right. So if you imagine that and then imagine that along one axis, right. And then along the other axis, you imagine that every company that could possibly advertise a product is doing so because there's just an ease of onboarding that invites them into this ecosystem. I mean, this is a massively accretive opportunity. Right? I mean, this is just an enlargement, a considerable enlargement of this economy. And so my concept of commerce at the limit is that every link in this value chain operates at maximum possible efficiency. Right. And so just going back to this diagram from before, like measurement and attribution, product personalization and monetization, campaign optimization and creative production, all of these things sort of attain maximum potential efficiency. And there's just, you know, just thinking through that. I mean, there's significant opportunity for expansion. So just some of the downstream consequences of commerce at the limit. So the first, I think the most obvious, is to increase participation. So at its limit, commerce expands the advertising economy to every business that could possibly benefit from it. Right. So the sort of light bulb moment for this was when I was in Houston, where I'm from, and I was flying out to give a talk the next day, and I needed a haircut. And I went on Google, and it's just almost impossible to find a barber. Like, if you, you know, if you go to a barber, you probably just, like, walked by it and thought, I'll try that out. It's near my house. But if you're in a new place, it's really difficult to find a barber and to understand if it's any good. Right. And so I went on Google, and I found one. It was terrible. It was horrible. But I was thinking, this barber shop could be advertising. Imagine. And that's inventory or that's an audience that's probably not being effectively monetized at this moment because it's not having local businesses advertise to it. Right. And so you've probably got this uncompetitive audience with. Very. That's very cheap to reach. That is essentially not being monetized. And you've got an entire group of, not just barbershops, but also nail salons and other businesses that aren't participating in this economy. And so you get more commerce from these companies because they're able to reach customers that they otherwise never would have been able to. And then you've got on the channel side, the ad channel side, you're actually monetizing this group of people with ads that are targeted to them, who otherwise just would have seen remnant inventory. So on both sides, you're sort of expanding that economy, which probably leads to price inflation, right. So as all ads perform to their maximum potential and all advertisers compete on equal footing, bids become the auction focus. So if everyone's ad is sort of maximally constructed or optimally constructed for conversion, then how do you beat someone in the auction? Right. So because the auction is just an expected value ordinal ranking. How do you beat someone? You have a higher bid, right? So I need to monetize my product better. That forces me to monetize my product better to have a higher bid to push into the auction. And then the ad channel just generates more revenue. And then personalization becomes imperative. So with advertising mostly automated, advertisers will shift development and analytics resources to in-product personalization. These improvements will surface better quality signals that can be passed to their channel partners for optimization. Right. So this kind of puts the imperative if I historically just outsourced a lot of that optimization to my ad channel partners, and I just had my product that I advertised; it's a singular product experience. Everyone had the exact same experience. Right? And I outsourced a lot of the personalization to the ad platforms based on who got targeted or maybe which of these dozen creatives was shown. But now the platform is managing all of that at the very top of the funnel. The only way for me to optimize my own business is to make sure that everyone gets the optimal product experience. So that pushes a lot of that personalization effort onto me. Whereas before, the ad platform sort of owned that aspect, finishing exactly on time. So, thanks very much. Um, and I'll look forward to the Q&A after.
Wow, Eric, thank you so much. Really inspirational. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and your insights on the industry. As you see, we're really starting to go down the rabbit hole now. And I would really like you to follow the White Rabbit together with me. Um, when I joined Verve and had my first days at the Berlin office, it was so inspirational to me. Just like listening to Eric now, seeing the people working there, having discussions in the meeting rooms. The whiteboards were full. They even started doing paintings on the glass doors because everything was full and they were just so creative. And it's really, um, that is the reason why I wanted to work for Verve and why I think we have a lot ahead of us from all the big tech brains, um, that you will meet at Verve Group. I'm now bringing you two further really good tech brains to present to you the next two presentations. One is Michelle Allen, the CEO of Verve Group, and afterwards Paul Hatton, our CTO of Data Set. So I can tell you this is going to be intense. Buckle up, ladies and gentlemen.
All right. Thank you so much, Ingo. And thank you, Eric. Uh, good afternoon everyone. It's great to be here again. Uh, some of you probably remember I was here exactly a year ago, the same month that June Group was acquired by Verve. And it's been an amazing year. I know that one of the questions that was asked earlier was about how it's going. And I want to answer that before we get to the topic of the presentation. And it's all in a way related. So it's been exactly a year since we were acquired. And if I had to just describe how this year has gone, I would say that it's been a masterclass of how a well-designed and executed integration should work. And the way I think about it is that the team we brought in from the group side, which Remco was referring to, is very tight. We haven't lost a single person from that strong team that we've had over the years. So, as I mentioned earlier, we had a strong team of individuals who were part of the senior management team and have been with the company for anywhere from eight to 14 years. We haven't lost a single person, and that's something that I don't take for granted and I'm really proud of. It's been an amazing journey with Verve and we're just getting started. So let's talk about idealist advertising. Obviously, it's a big topic. We've been talking about it already today, around the moats that we have in the industry and how Verve is well-positioned to win in this market. Uh, that includes ideas and also idealist environments which are evolving. I'm going to cover it from multiple directions. I'm going to talk about it from a demand perspective and also from a supply perspective. When I think about the demand perspective, it can be described as working with advertisers and collaborating with agency professionals who are seeking partners to run their campaigns. That's the demand side. And then on the supply side, where do you place those ads? Where do you find the relevant audiences for your advertising campaigns? And we are in a very unique position where we can work with both, and we work with both, and we're able to show results and outcomes for our clients. Um, we at Verve are very focused on outcomes. And my main goal in terms of outcomes in this presentation is, if I ask you what ideal advertising is after this session, everyone will know how to answer that question. I'm going to use a few real-life examples that hopefully will make it easier to understand. All right. So I'm going to start with a couple of questions by show of hands. Who here is concerned about privacy when it comes to advertising? All right. The majority of the room. And the second question is by show of hands, who in this room feels like they have a good understanding of how targeting actually works in the advertising space? And my main goal in terms of outcomes in this presentation is, if I ask you what is ideal advertising after this session, everyone will know how to answer that question. Small proportion. So again, my goal is that by the end of this presentation, everyone will be able to raise their hands. All right. Let's start from the demand side of the business. Again, demand is working with advertisers. Verve has made a few acquisitions, including a couple of notable ones in the demand space. One of them, obviously, is June Group, which I mentioned was acquired a year ago. The second one is Dataset. Dataset. I'm going to talk more about the products that we have, the solutions that we have for our clients. Both of those companies that were acquired were super focused on a privacy-first approach to reaching audiences. We're doing it from different directions, taking various angles to approach it. But at the core of what we do, we want to be in a position where we are able to perform for our clients while also respecting privacy regulations, privacy laws, and privacy best practices from the Apples and Googles of the world. If I double-click on Verve dataset for a second, in 2019, Apple introduced to the market a concept called ITP. The concept revolved around how to limit the usage of cookies in Safari browsers on mobile. Because the founders of Dataset, Paul and David, learned from Apple for many, many years, they knew that it was just a first indication of what Apple was going to do in a broader way when it comes to mobile in-app advertising, and that it would not be limited just to the browser environments on the devices. And over the years, we've spent a lot of time looking into what Apple was doing and learning their practices. And I'm going to get into that more later in the presentation. When we think about the TAM and the future, they are only going to get bigger and bigger as time goes by. So that vision in 2021 became a reality with the introduction of ATT, where, as Remco showed earlier in the presentation, when you install a new app, the app will prompt you with a message asking if you are willing to share information across apps to be targeted across apps? And 80% of the users say no to that. This does not stop GDPR, the evolving regulations in the US around privacy laws. That's all going to continue, and being strong when it comes to respecting privacy regulations and best practices is going to become more challenging, while also creating a lot of opportunities for us because we are the experts in this space. So how does it work? I think that it's really important to define both ID-based and idealist approaches, just so you get a full and holistic sense of how this actually works. Let's start from ID-based, and I'm going to use a simple example to explain how ID-based advertising works. At the core of ID-based advertising, you have a value, an ID, that you tie information to. When you tie that information, you basically create a profile, a behavioral profile that you can then use for targeting. So let's use a simple example. Let's say someone is single and they're looking to start dating. They install Tinder. Um, they start swiping left and right. They schedule a date night. It all goes well. They want to watch a show on Netflix. They install Netflix. They want to order some food, so they will order something from Deliveroo. Let's say some Vietnamese food. And it's all going great. And at some point, they decide to book travel. What happened there in the background is that there are third-party partners called MMPs, Mobile Measurement Partners, who will take all these signals that I just mentioned. What did the user install when, etc. And they will build a profile for that user. And you can see the profile that is being built for Alex in that example. Um, and you see what kind of data points will be added to that profile. Now if there is an ID available there, then it will tie that information to the ID, it will be sold to advertisers, and then advertisers will use that information to target the relevant users. So in this example, you know, this person booked travel via Expedia. And the next thing that you'll see is that they are now being targeted by an ad from Booking, encouraging them to book travel via Booking.com to the same destination they intended to visit, like Barcelona in this example. Uh, trying to convince them to book via Booking.com. You can take it one step further and use the additional information that you got, for example, the type of food that the person ordered, and use that also as another adjustment to the targeting. Now you're probably asking yourselves, wait, you just heard that 80% of the users on iOS are not even going to say yes to cross-app targeting. So how do these profiles get built? The answer is that those apps I mentioned, the mobile measurement partners—consider them as players in the market responsible for aggregating data and creating profiles around users—are taking an approach referred to in the industry as fingerprinting. What is fingerprinting? You basically take the data points that you have about the user, and you build a profile around that. So those data points could be the IP address. Every device that gets connected to the internet has an IP address. So they will take that information and they'll try to combine it with other information that they have. For example, the type of device that the user is using. Let's say they're using 16 Macs. And you know, you take those data points, combine them, and you create a fingerprint for the user. The issue with that is that it's a gray area right now. And we're going to talk more about what Apple is planning to do down the road around it. And it's also not always very accurate. For example, in this room, anyone who is connected to the Wi-Fi is sharing the same IP address with the external world. So if there are two people who have the same type of device, which is very common, and they click on an ad and make an install, for example. That attribution might get conflicted between those two individuals. So, you don't know who the user is. That is actually the one that installed the app in this example. So it has, you know, issues and limitations. And it's also not always very accurate. So those are aspects that you want to keep in mind. On the other side is the ideal approach of contextual targeting. And when it comes to contextual targeting, there are many different approaches that you can take in order to find the right context in which your target audience is. What you're seeing here is the way that we're doing it on our end, which is you basically look at the overall context where the user is coming from holistically, and that includes the publisher that they're visiting, the time of day, the geo-location, and based on the type of advertisers that you work with and the type of campaign that you're running. For example, if I go back to the example I mentioned earlier today, earlier in this presentation, if I think about the dating app, the time of day will play a bigger role in terms of giving you an indication of whether it's the right audience to reach. Publisher is always an important part of the context that we use in order to target the right audiences. And, you know, it could be language, it could be time of day, it could be geo; many different signals that we take from the context in which the user is in to make the right decisions. Now, this approach, the idealist approach that we're taking, we're going to talk in a minute. Like who is working with us in this capacity? But if you know what you're doing and you do it right, you're able to deliver great outcomes for the advertisers. So you're able to be in a position where you perform for the clients while also respecting privacy laws. There is something happening in the background. I mentioned regulation. Obviously, that's an important part. But there is also the overall Apple approach. As I mentioned earlier, Apple in 2019 started caring more and more about privacy, and over time that became a bigger priority for them. At some point, they decided that instead of letting those measurement partners, also known as mobile measurement partners, do the tracking, Apple wanted to control it. Apple wanted to be the source of truth when it comes to attribution. They wanted to be the ones who are providing information to the advertisers about which campaigns are effective and how the performance of their campaign is progressing. Obviously, it's also benefiting Apple to be the one controlling the truth and the information. So, there is that. So they came out with this concept called SKAdNetwork, where they are the ones who are responsible for providing that information. So let me use another simple example to describe how it works. Let's say, you know, Alex from our team has a pizza shop, and Alex really wants to promote his pizza shop to audiences. It prints out flyers and starts distributing them to individuals. If you take an ad-based approach, then you want to know that, for example, Samir received a flyer from Alex, and he ended up coming to the pizza shop and making a purchase. That's ID-based advertising. However, Apple said with the introduction of SKAdNetwork, we're not going to allow that. We're still going to allow you to track how the flyers that you are giving out are working, but we're going to do it in aggregate. So what Apple did is, Alex, you know, delivers, let's say 100 flyers per day. And it does that with different colors, different font types, different times of day. Apple will inform them about the performance of these flyer campaigns in aggregate, but they won't disclose that individual X, Y, or Z are the ones who came into the store. They will tell them your campaign or the creative that you used in the morning was able to deliver X purchases, and the campaign that you did in the evening with pink instead of black delivered Y number of purchases. And that's the approach that Apple is pushing for in the industry as a whole. And as part of that, they're trying to continue their efforts against fingerprinting and work towards banning it. There's another thing that is happening in the background. The introduction of LMS has resulted in fewer users and less traffic going to web publishers. Because of that, there is a need, even an increasing need, for advertisers to reach audiences on mobile. Why? Mobile is one of the only places where you can reach an individual and not a bigger group. When you run a CTV campaign, you reach a household. When you run a digital out-of-home campaign, you reach an even broader audience. The thing is, if you want to reach an individual, you need to rely on mobile. Thus, this is creating an environment where mobile is going to continue growing in size. And that context is even more important when you think about the overall opportunity that we have here in terms of TAM. So in the US, over 50% of the users use iOS. Whereas in Europe, it's a lower percentage, closer to 30%. Another thing that is interesting about the US market when it comes to iOS versus Android is that many marketers, many advertisers, are actually trying to reach iOS users. But reaching iOS users is becoming more and more difficult for those who are relying on ad-based advertising for the reasons I just mentioned. So if you think about it from that perspective, and if indeed Apple goes and bans fingerprinting, that's going to at least tenfold our opportunity in terms of promoting our idealist solutions in the market. Why do we think that can happen? Apple did something very interesting in iOS 16, which will become available in September. They banned fingerprinting when it comes to the Safari browser. So they're not doing it in in-app yet. But as we just discussed earlier, when they do something on Safari, in many cases it's an indicator for what they're going to do in the overall in-app environment. And if indeed they ban fingerprinting in in-app, that's going to continue accelerating our growth when it comes to our ideal solutions from a demand perspective. So I was alluding to this slide earlier. Who do we work with when it comes to these types of solutions? We work with the biggest names in the world. Just think about it for a second. Apple created SKAdNetwork. They are the ones behind all that is happening in terms of privacy laws and privacy best practices on iOS. They are the ones behind all that is happening in terms of privacy laws and privacy best practices on iOS. They work with us to promote their products and apps. So Apple is the one creating it, and they trust us because we are capable of delivering results for them. That's huge. It doesn't stop with Apple. I don't think I need to go into all the names on this slide. It just shows you the strength of the products and capabilities we have in this market, in terms of the outcomes that our advertisers are looking for. They're pretty broad. Depends on the advertiser. It could be as simple as impressions and reach, or it could be more involved in terms of the funnel, including installs, subscriptions, and post-install events. You want to know what happens with the user after the install happens, and we are able to deliver those outcomes for our clients at scale. So let's take a look at one example. Auto Aramco mentioned them earlier today. Third biggest retailer in Germany, which is very focused on privacy-based approaches to advertising. We've been working with them for almost a year, and the return on ad spend has been significant for them. And Eric mentioned return on ad spend earlier. At the end of the day, it's all about how much I invest in my campaigns and how much I get back from an increase in sales or whatever KPI the client has. So this product is performing for them, and when it performs for them, they continue working with us because it's a no-brainer for them to do that with Otto specifically. We're also giving them visibility into post-view events. So the user watched the ad, installed an app. What happens next? Are they spending on the app? Are they making purchases? If you are operating in an idealist environment and you don't have the capabilities that we have built over the years, you don't have visibility into those. So we are uniquely positioned to deliver those types of insights for our clients. And that's another reason why they want to continue working with us. Another approach that we take when it comes to ideals or privacy. First, advertising involves our zero party data. Earlier today, you heard the concept of first-party data mentioned. First party is information that you get from the publisher itself. Zero party data is where you take it one step further and get it directly from the user. So the user is volunteering information that you can then use for targeting. So, in this example, you're looking at asking a user if they're interested in buying new sneakers. If they want to answer the question, they'll answer it. If they don't, they don't have to. And based on the response they give you, you are able to adjust the ad experience for them. We've been doing this at scale on the June side for many years, and now it's offered across the board as part of our brand and agency offering. Um, in the US and in other markets. And here I also have another case study that we did for Mars. Um, it was for a pet product. So we asked the user, do you have a pet? And based on the ones that said yes, we delivered the relevant ad, and the return on ad spend was significant. And in terms of outcomes, this client was able to see a significant increment in sales, which in return drove them to continue working with us and spending more with us. So I covered the demand side. Let's spend a minute on the supply side. So when iOS 8 came out, what happened was the DSPs, the demand side platforms, had less visibility into the users from whom they were getting requests. Why? There was no data available. They could not use data to target. They were blind to what was happening. As a result, there was a significant decrease in effective CPMs. That decrease impacted both the demand side and also the publishers. But what's interesting is that publishers still had a lot of access to data. But the key was how you use that data, and how you create an environment where you still drive value for the consumer and also for the advertiser? So there was a huge opportunity there, and we decided when we saw that opportunity to get into that space in a way that was unique, and that way was Atom. Atom gives you the ability to identify your target audiences on the device without any sensitive information leaving the device. This on-device targeting capability that we have gives us the ability to identify cohorts of users. And when we identify those cohorts of users, we're able to pass it back in a privacy-compliant way so advertisers can use that to target the right audiences. We are again uniquely positioned with this solution, and it gives us the ability not only to look at things from a demand perspective, but also from a supply perspective. So let's show you a quick video of what Atom is.
In a mobile-first world where engagement drives revenue. Advertisers face a paradox of reaching the right users at scale without compromising privacy. Embedded in hundreds of millions of devices, Atom unlocks mobile inventory at unprecedented scale. Through integration with the Verve SDK, atom connects advertisers to one of the largest mobile programmatic ecosystems in real time. Atom is built on a privacy-first architecture. No personal data, no tracking IDs, no server-side profiling. Everything stays on device. On mobile, Atom breaks through ID limitations, generating real-time on-device cohort intelligence even in ID restricted environments using on-device behavioral analysis. Adam produces predictive, privacy-safe cohorts with up to 90% accuracy in inferring user attributes. Advertisers can choose from over 200 behavioral and contextual cohorts or build their own for publishers. Adam powers real-time insights that reshape how inventory is valued, optimized, and activated. The future of mobile ad targeting is private, intelligent, and scalable. Adam. Make every impression count.
So you saw a few examples of audiences and cohorts that were mentioned there. So, Adam will take the information that we are getting directly from the device, ensuring it does not leave the device to calculate the cohort. So, for example, someone who is very active in the morning will be profiled as such. Obviously, it would take a lot of data points. Uh, we have over 180 signals that we take into account to calculate those cohorts. Uh, but there is a lot that is happening in the background. And what's basically happening is that you have AI that is distributed across many devices, and Paul is going to talk more about that in his presentation. So how does this all come together and what are we going to do next? AI is really at the core of what we do in terms of what I described from a demand perspective and supply perspective, and we are currently working on the next generation products where we bring all that together. Our goal is to continue delivering better outcomes for our clients. When we provide those better outcomes, they tend to spend more with us. They trust us. Then they rely on our ability to generate the outcomes that they're looking for. And it also creates an opportunity for us to become more efficient. AI has a lot of efficiency promise in it. And again, Paul is going to spend a lot more time talking about it. But our goal is to continue optimizing our campaigns, deliver better outcomes, and do it in a more efficient way. So just to wrap things up, uh, when it comes to ad-based or ID-less targeting, our approach is to use what we have access to. When we have access to ideas, we will use them as long as it's compliant with the privacy laws. But when we don't have access to IDs, then we will use our secret sauce, which gives us the ability to succeed in the market. And that puts us in a very unique position overall in the market. And the opportunity, as I mentioned, is going to continue growing. It's going to continue growing in terms of our ability to deliver outcomes for our advertisers. It's going to continue growing in terms of our ability to strengthen the relationships with publishers by driving better results for them and better revenue. And it's also going to give us the ability to be at the forefront of what's happening in the industry because, again, our capabilities in this space are very unique, and we're going to continue investing and building on them. So we're just scratching the surface. We're going to continue evolving our products and offerings. And I'm going to let Paul talk more about that. Thank you.
Thank you.
Good afternoon everybody. Artificial intelligence has been part of adtech for over ten years. It's grown steadily in its importance and its power with each year that's gone by. Over the next 30 minutes, we're going to have a very quick tour through the AI that powers the advertising platform. We're going to look at the AI that allows us to be more productive and more efficient, and we're going to look at the AI innovations that make the difference, that make us unique, that stand us apart from the rest of the industry. My name is Paul Hatton. I joined Verve three years ago. I am the co-founder and CTO of Dataset. Our contextual demand-side platform. I began my career in academia quite a while ago now. I was a university researcher for five years at the Neural Networks Research Group at Oxford University, researching applications of neural networks. I've been part of adtech since 2011, but it's great to be here to talk about a subject that I enjoy so much, which is artificial intelligence. Before we get too much into our tour of AI, allow me to provide some clarifications, shall we say. AI involves taking data and training a model that captures underlying patterns, generalizes what the data represents, learns the truth from which that data is derived, and from there, it can make predictions, classifications, and decisions. In the past, it has usually been about taking a particular set of data for a particular task. For instance, you take images of road signs and train an AI to recognize speed limits, which can then be displayed on the dashboard of your car as you're driving along. One particular task I recently mentioned is that we've started seeing large language models come along in the last year or so, and they're trained on language. They're trained to provide an appropriate response to a prompt or a question. And this gives us a whole new set of opportunities in ways we can utilize it to drive better outcomes and efficiency. But we do need to watch out, though, because AI is not perfect. There are many well-known examples. See, AI is great if you take some data and give it another question or input that is similar to the one it's been trained on. It'll do a great job of providing a very accurate prediction if it's within the scope of the training data it had. If you ask it to do something that it's never seen before, it will often fall flat on its face. If you ask ChatGPT for a picture of a person writing with their left hand. You will get a picture of a person writing with their right hand. If you ask for a picture of someone wearing a jacket inside out, you will just get a picture of someone wearing a jacket. You've asked for something that has never been seen before, and it just collapses and does something completely unpredictable. So you've just got to be aware of what it can do and what it can't do. It often doesn't capture the truth that's underneath it. It just learns from what it's seen. So onwards we go into our three chapters of our tour. First of all, we're going to look at ad targeting. What's in this? What's at the heart of an advertising platform is the need for data, how we match advertisers and consumers, and how we optimize for KPIs. We're going to look at efficiency, the tools we use, intelligent AI, and our strategic cooperation with Google, and how that is going to enable us to produce better AI models going forwards. And lastly, differentiation. The things that make us different, the things that make us stand out, what makes us unique and what gives us that competitive edge. Atom data set and helix. So going into the first chapter targeting within Verve. First off, we need to recognize that we need data. In fact, there are three things you need to build an AI. You need a lot of data. You need a lot of computing power. And you need a team of data scientists who understand how to get the most out of those things. And we have all three at Verve. We have a huge amount of data, trillions of pieces of data from our exchange, and millions of bits of data from our SDK, coming from those devices that have our SDK installed. And then we've got ID graphs that link between different devices that a user owns and uses. We can also take in external data from other sources like Experian, and all that data can come together in what looks very simple, because it's just a triangle on the screen of AI optimization. It's really an opportunity to use all that data and optimize it to provide the best ad served to the right target group. That's our goal. Now, what's inside that triangle of AI optimization is a lot more complex than it looks. So we're going to dive in and have a look and see inside. See, our net revenue that we get out is a function of a whole bunch of things. The ad requests that we send out, we receive back in the form of a bid rate, which indicates how often our demand partners are bidding in the auctions that we're supplying, and how often they are winning, because if they don't win, it means nothing to them or to us. The revenue share that we get is based on the CPM, which is the pricing that they're bidding. The higher they bid, the better for us, the better for our publishers, and the render rates. Whether or not those adverts actually show, all of those aspects of this process can be optimized. All of those present opportunities for us to optimize them with AI models. We're going to pick up on just one of them and look at the impact it has. But there are lots of initiatives on the screen there. Demand shaping and bid pricing are crucial aspects. Helix. We're going to touch on some of them, but we haven't got time to go into all of them in detail. But just picking up one and the impact it has for us. Demand shaping involves evaluating all available ad requests we can access and deciding which ones to send to our demand partners. It's like fishing. It's like putting the right bait on the right hook. If you do it right, you get lots of bids back at high CPM, high prices. You lose money if you do it wrong. You get no bids back. We have access to an absolutely enormous amount of available advert opportunities. This is over a 31-day period. There were 1.251 trillion opportunities to show advert requests. Of those, we're picking out the 2 to 3% where there's a very, very high chance that our demand partners will want to show an advert where everything matches the right geography, the right type of publishers, and the right demographics. If that's done well, it's a huge efficiency gain. If we get it wrong, it costs us a lot of money. So this is demand shaping at its best. And this has had a huge impact. We routinely measured the impact of this versus not doing it. It has a huge boost in revenue. But we can do better. We can make this more granular. This is a constantly evolving, constantly improving piece of technology because our demand partners change their strategies regularly. They're constantly evolving too; they're doing more subtle bidding on our inventory. So we have to make sure our demand shaping matches the supply with the requests that they want to bid on. To do that, we're looking to use more complex models, including, for instance, deep neural networks. They are super complex. They are harder to train, but they provide us with the most effective means of generalizing underlying patterns that you can have. We're also looking at using a technique called reinforcement learning that will allow us to have a model that's trained and adapt as new data comes in. It's not static. It continues to learn in real-time as new data arrives, adapting to changes seamlessly. So if our demand partners change what they're doing, the model will change what it supplies. This allows us to have more complex models that are trained less frequently, because training them is the costly part of it. So we've looked at one example of an AI technique within Verve among quite a few that are in place, and these AI techniques allow us to select the adverts that we supply to our demand partners. They allow us to optimize the number of adverts that we show, and they allow us to maximize the revenue and the margin that we take as a business. Now we have to move on to the second chapter of our tour, which is about efficiency. We're going to look at three aspects of team efficiency. I'm going to give you an example of one intelligent AI, an intelligent UI that we've built, and our strategic collaboration with Google. First of all, team efficiency. We, as well as building AI tools. We are also consumers of AI. We have the opportunity to utilize AI to enhance our productivity and efficiency. As I'm sure many of you have tried playing around with AI tools, we are the same. So we've started activating certain AI tools, making them available for our teams in an evaluation mode, shall we say, because not all AIs are created equal. There have been academic studies that have shown that some AI tools actually decrease productivity. They're more gimmick than they are tool. So what we're doing is evaluating how well these work, how much efficiency improvement we get, where we become more productive, and where they're just a distraction. So we have GitHub Copilot, which is an AI for our developers aiming to lessen the amount of typing they have to do because it predicts what they're starting to code and offers completions. And it can pick up on that for you and highlight it. CodeRabbit is an interesting AI tool that does code reviews for you. Now, developers like solving problems. Uh, they don't particularly like typing. They like solving problems, and they like coding. They don't tend to like reviewing other people's code so much. It's a necessary part of the job, but it's not people's favorite aspect of their workday, particularly with coding. Rabbit does a basic review for you. It picks up on occasions of bad practice or imperfect structures. It can speed up that review process by highlighting, as a first pass, things that could be improved. We understand that we are not going to eliminate the human code reviewer. But we can make their lives a little bit easier. We also have Gemini. Google Gemini is integrated into our entire organization, allowing us to ask Gemini for answers instead of searching through documents. But the way to do this is not just to enable all these tools and hope we are doing it in a structured way. We have an overview of which tools are active, and we ensure they are beneficial by validating that they are actually providing us with productivity improvements and offering guidance for best practices to our team. We need to have a proper rollout of the tools that we agree. The ones we find do give us productivity improvements, and we also need to be careful that we're not disclosing information by using AI. We need to make sure that these AIs are effectively closed. The data we put into them doesn't go and get used for further language model training, and that way we get the most out of them, ensuring that we benefit and don't get hindered. Another way in which we can be efficient is to take advantage of the new large language model, stylize, and build an Agentic AI user interface. As an example, this is a media brief or a media plan. These are used by our users to create what's called a deal. A deal is a segment of advertising inventory chosen for a particular advertiser campaign. It might be set up to target a particular geography, with a specific set of advertising formats on a group of publishers aimed at a particular type of person. And typically, a media brief will be a document which will list a whole set of objectives. It'll give some dates, as you can see here, an audience that you're trying to reach. Um, some, some, in this case, various deals. We want to do some display and we want to do some video. And the traditional way of doing this is through a user interface that we've always had. A user interface designed for this task requires setting up multiple controls, selectors, and date boxes, which involves considerable time and effort. But understanding a document is what a large language model does brilliantly. And so what we've got under development is an Agentic AI, an intelligent UI. This is our next-generation deal portal, and we're going to demonstrate it. What we're going to show is that we can upload that media plan. The large language model will process it and summarize it, because summarizing is a huge strength of these models. Pick out the key features and produce the deals. So let's have a look. This is the UI and we'll watch it go. We select the Upload a File button. We're going to select that file, that media plan, and upload it. The large language model processes or passes through that document, picking out the key features. The key features. And it generates—though 'spits out' might not be the ideal phrase—the deals that it believes should accompany that media brief. So let's go back to the top and we'll have a little look at what it found. It passed the media plan. From the summary, you can see it's picked up the relevant information. The fact is that this media brief is to take Verve Supply and send it to the Trade Desk. It's picked out the dates and it's figured out that it needs eight deals for display, deals for video deals, and those are listed below as queries that it used from the deals that are available to. And it's produced some forecasts and suggested price points. And so, having reviewed all those, we can either decide that we want to refine it by adding some more instructions to change it in this manner, or we can, if we're happy, just say, let's create the deals. And when we create the deals, we transition to a more standard interface. We can see all the deals ready to go, and if we're happy, we just hit save. And those are then being trafficked from Verve Supply to the Trade Desk in a matter of seconds, whereas previously this would have taken, at best, minutes. So we can use the power of large language models to give us an intelligent user interface, one that makes life easy, doesn't require extensive training, and allows people to get things set up quickly. The third aspect of efficiency is our Google Cloud partnership, having moved onto Google Cloud. We have lots of opportunities and we're going to look at three of them. The first is we can upscale or upskill our data science and machine learning operations. We have access to better tools. We can take advantage of Vertex AI. We can look at and use state-of-the-art notebook environments for our data scientists. This allows them to efficiently prototype, test, and put into production a new AI model. So if you can do that, you can try things faster. You can get through the things that don't work and find the things that do work. And then you produce AI at scale in an efficient manner. We're also, as I mentioned briefly, looking at reinforcement learning so that we can take a trained model and adapt it, or let it adapt itself as it sees new data coming in. So it isn't just trained; it becomes something that is being trained on an ongoing basis. It's trained throughout its time. This means we can use a more complex model, it gets trained less often, and it adapts to the data it sees in real time. The third aspect is to begin approaching deep neural networks. These are the most complex architectures of neural networks. We have one deep neural network in production that I'm aware of in Verve, which operates within a specific dataset. Um, it does recommendations, but it doesn't have to do that in real time. We're looking to see if we can use deep neural networks at scale. Um, it is difficult to get them right because the complexity can be anything from simple to enormous. So, it does take specialist knowledge. The revenue impact that this could have is yet to be seen. This is something that will take us. We're beginning the journey now, but this is something that will bear fruit. So we've looked at AI tools that allow us to be more productive and more efficient. Our Google Cloud partnership allows our data scientists to transition from an idea to a prototype much faster with state-of-the-art machine learning operations. And we've looked at our Agentic AI user interface, an intelligent user interface that saves time and allows humans to do the tasks that they do best, not just typing numbers into boxes. And so we'll move on to the last chapter of our tour, which is what makes us different, what makes Verve unique amongst the rest of the industry. Now we're going to look at atom. We're going to look at data and we're going to look at helix. So, privacy, we've mentioned it quite a lot today. Various people have mentioned it already. And Michels mentioned atom. But I want to dive into some of the highlights of what Atom does. Privacy is super important. We've always believed in it as being important, but it does mean that you're asking users if they want to share their data? And if you don't, that's okay. But if users don't share that data, it means you have no data to train an AI. That means you need to find other ways to optimize, other ways to train models. Privacy protects users' data. That means we have to do different things with AIs in response. And the answer, as you've heard a lot about, or one of the answers that you've heard about, is Atom. Now, what Atom does is it looks at all the signals. The thing that is amazing about Atom, just before I dive into what it does, is it's an AI that's on users' devices. It's inside their iPhones or their Android devices. It's running there. So it's there in millions of devices and it's running all the time. It's listening for signals. Device content. What's going on on that device, the apps that they're using, how well that user engages with their app, how much attention they provide to different parts of the app, and whether they engage in adverts. All of these features, these hundred signals, are going into the AI that's on that device. It's being trained, it's out there in our SDK. It's taken a long time to get there. It's now on its upward growth trajectory, where AI can provide us with these cohorts: 200 different categorized, classified groups that AI listens to through these signals. And when it gets to a certain point, it will say, okay, I have a high probability now that this user is currently at home or this user is interested in video games, or this user is of a high income demographic. That data does not breach someone's privacy. It's not identifying the person by saying where they live and who they are. You can't link it to other data, but it's invaluable for advert targeting. It's invaluable for showing the right adverts to the right groups of users. And that's the reason why this technology is so revolutionary in the realm of digital advertising. Well, this will be like a drug to demand partners because once you get addicted, you can't get off it. Um, this will be something that will drive up prices because it's going to be super valuable for targeting, as an example of one of those. I mean, I have a teenage daughter. She uses her phone in a very different way compared to me. Um, her fingers tap away at it at a much higher speed than I could ever hope to match. So looking at the way people pinch, tap, and zoom on their devices are the kind of features and signals that allow atom to classify into one demographic, in this case, 18 to 24. Oh, sorry, not the features, but those classified cohorts get sent to our demand partners, our demand partners that can then appropriately choose the advertising campaign that is right for that user. And we get better advertising while upholding people's privacy. Atom has been scaling up. You've heard about it for a long time because it's been in development and slowly rolling out, but it's now really on that upward trajectory. On iOS, there are 700 apps now with our SDK, with Atom running, producing ad requests with Atom cohorts, 1.7 billion ad requests per day from 700 apps. Android was released more recently, in June. There are currently 40 apps, sending atom cohorts 3.33 million requests per day. And there's a lot more to come as this gets bigger in scale, making it more important and driving up prices for advertising. So, we've looked at, um, so yeah, we've looked at Atom. And one of the customers of Atom, dear to my heart, is Data Seat because Data Seat is a contextual bidder. Um, data seat relies on contextual features. Things like the publisher app that a user is in, how long they've been using the app, and the city they are currently residing in. And now we can also look at the atom cohorts as an extra feature. Those features together are what go into the Data Seat AI models, allowing our models to pick out the optimum bid price, or the value of showing an advert to a given user for a given campaign. The cohorts get bigger as well. And it's a virtuous circle because the advertising gets better and better. As well as providing data. We've also talked about, well, we've talked a bit about audiences and deals through our deal portal. Um, when we're looking at providing an audience as a different sort of aspect of what we're doing here, if we're looking at providing an audience and making that available for our demand partners or for advertisers to use, we now have this split between data that's got IDs in it and data that is ID-less, personally identifiable information and non-personally identifiable information. In iOS, it's at about 75%. Doesn't have IDs, no personally identifiable information; 25% does on Android. It's kind of the other way around. Around 80% have IDs, while 20% do not have IDs. And so the challenge is you've got this split. And what we really want is to take the best of both worlds. We need something that gives us a unified view of all of this data, both ID-based and ID-less. We want to take all of it and put it into one single audience store. That way, we get everything, and we can monetize all of it. We can provide the best audience possible. And that is what we call Helix. It's an audience intelligence engine, covering both ID-based and ID-less. It gives scale where previous audiences would have only been based on IDs. Helix allows us to have an audience that covers ID-less as well. It covers all of our channels, CTV, in-app, and web to give us the maximum view of an audience. I'm going to demonstrate another AI user interface that allows us to get that audience as simply as possible. We can have a look at insights on what that audience will cover, who it will reach, where they'll be, and how they interlock with each other within those categories. We can optimize that audience as we go along by making changes to it and interacting with the prompts, and we can make that audience available when it's finished through our portal as Verve supplies traffic to a particular demand partner. So let's have a look. This is the user interface. It is quite small because this is a screenshot that we took on Thursday. Um, we went through various options, and we settled on the prompt we were going to use, which is 'people like me.' So I want to target men who are interested in electric cars and a healthy lifestyle. It's very, very simple. The prompt to use. The data that's in this tool at the moment is from the US. And so, what we get is a summary of what that audience will be. There can be 21 billion daily matches. That's not users. But that's matches, 2.4 billion from ID-based data and 18 billion from ID-based covering mobile, CTV, and web. We can also look at how the pieces of this audience interlock together: healthy living, sports, automotive, holidays, and the links between those to gauge behavior affinity. We can see the location of where this audience will be spread, and the different pieces that make it up, which are part of it. Healthy shoppers, some are travel, healthy living, and so on. We can look at the different ad formats that will be part of this audience, ranging from display to video, and we can examine the price point. We can look at what volume of inventory, what volume of our audience will get at any particular price value. So at $5, we'll be reaching about 50% of that available audience. Um, that'll be the cheaper inventory. If we go higher, we'll get more video inventory at a higher price point. So we've seen Atom, we've seen Dataset, and we've seen Helix—three parts of Verve that are quite unique and make us stand apart from everyone else. Helix addresses audiences across idealists and ID-based datasets, contextual DSP targets in a privacy-centric advertising setting, and Atom providing data from our SDKs that is not available in a privacy-based way from any other source. I'm going to finish by looking at our vision for the future going forward. This is a diagram of the Verve technology structure. We've got publishers and advertisers on the left. We've got our marketplace, Helix Control Center, Curation Center, and our DSP. Each of these pieces has an opportunity for AI optimization within our publishers. We've got Atom, which provides us with intelligence on the edge, giving us better data coming in. Our curation center is our deals portal that you saw earlier, where we can create packages of media very simply. In our control center, we're looking at techniques for anomaly detection, so we don't have to have humans staring at screens and metrics. Instead, we can train AI models to understand what's normal and let them flag anomalies. When we've gone outside of normality in our marketplace, we dove into demand shaping. But there are plenty of other techniques that were already in place, such as floor pricing and dynamic margins, to mention two. On our DSP side, we have pacing and targeting, but we're also looking at creative design and bid shading to get the optimum prices that we're bidding. And finally, Helix, which is our content intelligence platform, helps to provide an audience. The idea behind all of these is to use the right tool for the right job, leveraging AI to do what it does best, like taking data, generalizing it, and making classifications and predictions. Thank you very much.
Paul. Great. My head just exploded. Good. Thanks a lot. So now, may I ask Michelle and Eric back on stage as we're running for our second Q&A session back there? This is going to be the tech Q&A session. So we're not going for, um, financials here or anything. And I understand that I think we all don't have a PhD in AI, so there are no stupid questions. Please, just ask, as for everyone who asks a question. There will be somebody else in the room celebrating this guy for just asking because he didn't dare to. So I give you, as usual, please raise your hand, and then we'll bring you the microphone. Yes. Thank you so much.
Is it on?
Our curation center is our deals portal that you saw earlier, where we can create packages of media very simply. Now it's on.
I start with a stupid question. Oh, um. Well, I liked your presentations and I just wondered a bit, giving some context in terms of the competition. Um, well, uh, you historically gained market share when ID solutions in iOS were introduced, basically. So what are you thinking? Who is your closest competitor or best competitor, and how do your approaches differ from those of your competitors?
Thank you.
I can go first. I think that, uh.
A unique position in the market is that we're able to look at it from both a demand and supply perspective. There are not many players out there that have those types of perspectives. And I think that one example to highlight there is what Paul just described with the combination of the dataset and Atom. So you're able to take information from the supply side, make it available to the demand side. On this side, in a way that makes our accuracy even higher. When it comes to our ability to target people at scale. Another thing to mention there is our SDK. There are many players out there that don't have that direct access to the supply, which gives us a lot of control and visibility into the ad experiences, into how much we pay out, and into our ability to protect our margins, etc. . And you know, when you think about it from those two angles, you understand the unique positioning that Verve has in the market.
So first, please come a bit closer to me so that our online viewers can also see you. That's a good point. You just stated about the SDKs because that seems to be a question a lot of our online audience has. Um, how does Adam get access to the devices referring to the SDKs and then how many other competitors in the market are offering similar SDKs, and how is the real competition in this market to bring your SDK into an app?
In terms of who has an SDK, the number of leading vendors in the space with SDKs is not that large. The reason for that is it takes many years to get your SDK from an engineering perspective to a place where it's stable, capable, and also drives the revenues that publishers are looking for. When you think about it from an app developer's perspective, they don't want to install more than, you know, 8 to 10 SDKs on their device. The reason for that is every SDK you add to your platform, you create some risk. If an SDK crashes, that can have an impact on your app. So you want to be very careful about who you integrate. And you have to be very selective to only include the ones that are the best performers. The way that it works is as part of the SDK integration. App developers have the ability to also add atom, and as you saw in one of the slides that Paul presented and also I presented where we've been able to scale things up. So we're looking at 1.7 billion auctions just on iOS on a daily basis. So that gives us a pretty robust user base.
And maybe one question to you, Eric, as the visionary on what might happen, there is a cohort of investors, I would say that do not dare to invest in such a tech company because they say, I cannot really predict if something completely new will come up and then push out all the players that are currently in the market. What would you answer to an investor stating something like that?
Yeah, that's a good question. So I think, um, you know, there's a structural resiliency that you'd want to look at in the company itself. Structural resiliency is something you'd want to examine within the company itself. Right. So, there was, I mean, it was like an extinction-level event, right. Um, you know, it's five years in the rearview mirror now, but a lot of DSPs went out of business, so a company that survived has proven resiliency, right. And, um, you know, adaptability. But just going back to the SDK comment, because that's actually a really important component. If you have the SDK, you essentially have that direct connection which gives you access to data in a way that eliminates the need for many privacy-violating measures. Right. I mean, you talk about. So, um, you know, Paul talked about it and you both talked about it, Adam, but doing that sort of edge inference is really important. And, like, there are other ways; there are privacy-preserving methods, like things called federated learning. Right. So, you can update the model from just the edge device without leaking any personal information. So that kind of capability, you know, is resilient to any sort of new intervention in the market. Um, would not sort of disrupt the ability to do that. Right. Um, but, you know, if you look at, you know, the issue with getting an SDK and I talk about this from the advertiser's side is that it's, it's, it's the bloat, right. But then, you know, to your point about the fragility, like every SDK adds essentially some new opportunity for your app to fail. And so, like, what a lot of advertisers do is they never implement an SDK. Like if you want my data, I'll send it on the back end. That's all MMP-based, right? So if you have an SDK, I mean that really is like a very deep connection. So I'd say that kind of footprint is really important in assessing the risk of any new privacy intervention.
I would also just add that I guess what sets us apart is we have a demand-side platform that's focused on privacy and contextual bidding, and a supply-side platform that's about providing the right signals for that. And that's a great link together. There are other companies with SDKs that just provide data. Please note that there are other companies engaged in bidding as well. But the two together, with that same synergy and vision of implementing ID-based advertising, complement each other effectively. That's how it works best.
Thank you.
Hello? Yeah. Can I just get some clarification? This is a little bit building on what has just been said. So if we say Atom. So, Atom B, Tom C, Tom. So competitors. So is it your point that we have atom and there are no comparable comparisons such as. Call it BCT, Tom. Is that what you said before?
There isn't another solution like Atom in any other SDK.
So we can tick the box here and say we are unique and we are market leading. So now you have mentioned before how many devices Atom is active in. Yeah. So is there not a technique to refer to this installed base that we have, basically an installed base. So if we are in, I think you said, in 2 billion devices, we are active in one of your charts. You said Atom is in 2 billion devices.
We are getting 1.7 billion auctions every day. Requests every day. So, you know, we have that data available at that scale, in terms of the installed base, we have about 700 apps on iOS that have atom enabled already.
Please bid and there are other companies that do bidding. But if we are in the device in the iPhone. Yeah. Is there value in terms of being in more iPhones? Yeah.
So 700 apps, each of those apps is said to have 1 million daily active users. That gives you 700 million people.
So I call this inReach. So we then have the reach into these hundreds of apps, 110 million devices, and so on. And is this not value that is difficult for competitors to match?
Absolutely.
Because they don't have the reach.
Yeah, absolutely.
And then, how do we systematically expand that reach? We spoke this morning about investing in the Salesforce. These are the 100 people you want to recruit. Accurately. But how do we systematically invest in expanding the reach?
Yeah, there is an effort on the supply side and on the marketplace side to increase that scale, to further increase that scale. So that's an ongoing initiative. We are at a point where the level, the volume that we're getting on a daily basis is significant. This is not, you know, a walk in the park type of volume when you think about it from a daily request perspective. We are constantly pushing that. So it will be an even bigger part because that increases our addressability. It's always tied to the demand. You know, at the end of the day, the side that needs to act on the information that comes from Atom is the demand side, which uses that information to target the right audiences on the SDK.
This is understood.
But the question, I just want to find out how strategic we are to expand the reach, because if we have the installed base, the region, all of this, we have a more credible source or quality of information argument on the demand side, which are you going to invest in in terms of the sales force?
Yeah, our goal is to have Atom enabled in as many apps as we have DirectX SDK reach into, and also to increase that volume on a daily basis, so that it will be even higher.
Maybe to add some words to that, to the question. Thanks for the question. Atom took a long time. I mean, we have been developing it for a long time. We have been testing it for a long time, and in the beginning, you have to be super careful if you put it in apps, because the worst thing is that the app crashes and that the publisher doesn't want to work with you anymore. So we had to scale it up slowly, and we now have a decent number of apps where we're in. So we want to roll it out everywhere. Correction to. Be careful. We are also still, let's say, carefully rolling that out. Sorry, not Atom. And on Android, I wanted to say we carefully roll it out. But on iOS, it's been proven that it works. It is at scale and the only thing now is to get more scale. So our account managers are here, including Sameer. Sameer's team is really pushing that extensively. We roll it out everywhere now and really get an installed base that is, uh, even bigger than where we are now. We are now at a scale where we can prove that it works. We get enough ad requests that we can make it really helpful and truly achieve the desired results. Paul was talking about higher prices for the publishers, but it's even more about achieving more results for the advertisers. And now it's really about further scaling that, and we have a competitive advantage with it. Sorry, I wanted to quickly fill in here.
Thank you for that. And maybe adding to this, the number one question that every tech company gets. If what you're doing is so sophisticated, why doesn't Google do it? And what would they have to go through to copy us?
There is a reluctance to let go of ID-based advertising. Um, there are quite a lot of companies out there who are still holding on to either the ID segment or trying to do attribution by fingerprinting. Um, because that's all they know how to do. Uh, eventually there will be more of a forced shift over. Um, I've mentioned the possibility of Apple absolutely, absolutely breaking fingerprinting. Breaking fingerprinting. Um, it's in their rules that you're not allowed to fingerprint, but people are kind of ignoring that and they're getting away with it at the moment. If that gets enforced, there'll be this seismic shift that Eric mentioned, really hitting and that everyone will be playing catch up at that point.
Thanks.
Any further questions here?
Yes. So a question for you, Eric. Maybe if you would like to sort of elaborate or give your thoughts or opinions on where the targeting is currently in terms of efficiency and overall accuracy compared to the sort of traditional idea-based targeting methods? Uh, just general thoughts. I believe it could be quite difficult for you to give any firm answers. But where are we currently? I guess it's still early days, but. Yeah.
Yeah. Um, so I could talk about the potential because I think if you look, I follow a lot of companies. So anyway, just to level set, I don't have any relationship with Verve. I was an advisor to Datacite. Um, but I don't have any affiliation with them. I'm here just to give a talk. Right. Um, not to promote Verve. Uh, but, uh, so I think if you look at the potential, I would just, I would use Facebook as the kind of guiding example here. And what they've done with Advantage Plus has essentially recovered completely from ID tracking issues. And I think one of the issues with ID-based advertising is that it kind of created this false sense of trust. Like, first of all, there was essentially no deterministic attribution. It just didn't really exist. But, you know, the presence of an ID made people a lot more comfortable with that concept. And once you pulled back from that and advertisers didn't have access to it anymore, you realized there were a lot of interaction effects that I was not giving credit to. Like, I was running this influencer campaign that I couldn't measure deterministically. And that was actually benefiting all the deterministic campaigns that I was measuring last click. And so what I think has happened is the whole market has moved away from the idea of last click. And so, there are very specific ways in which ID-based advertising is much more performant. But there are a lot of benefits to moving away from ID-based measurement that broadly, I would say, the cohort of advertisers has embraced. And so, when you embrace those things, you unlock a lot of capabilities that you would never use if you were totally tethered to ID-based advertising. And those are unlocked with probabilistic advertising and similar approaches. And that is a significant portion of the AI-driven initiatives. So I would say certainly there are downsides to not having the ID. You can't build a behavioral profile that's really helpful in a lot of cases, but when you're tethered to that, you don't do things like looking at interaction effects with CTV and/or TV-based campaigns and all that kind of stuff. And so the rise of everything as an ad network and the set of new channels that couldn't be deterministically measured anyway, has awakened people to the value of that. So I would say, yes, there are downsides, but I think on net everyone's sort of better off. And so, you know, it has created a lot of value, supporting those use cases with things like attribution and measurement.
Just to add quickly from a work perspective, if you consider that slide where I was showing who is working with us and what kind of outcomes we deliver for them, there is a set of advertisers that is more conscious about respecting privacy regulations and best practices. And those are the ones that would prefer to use the ID-less approach because they believe that’s the approach that should be used in the market. And, you know, I mentioned Apple is a great example of that. Uh, we expect that that market will continue to expand, uh, because of regulation, because of what Apple is doing. Uh, but at the same time, um, you know, when you think about those types of clients, they will not work with you if you're not able to produce outcomes and results for them in an ideal advertising environment. And if you consider some of the case studies that we showed. We are able to show that performance and deliver those outcomes in a way that makes the clients happy. And in the end of the day, it's all about outcomes. When we consider what we can do for our clients.
So I would say certainly there are downsides to not having the ID. Thanks. I think we have time for one last question. Do we have any further questions here? Did you want. I saw your hand earlier. Yeah.
Well, I hope it's not too stupid, but just technologically, we spoke about atom in apps. If I have an atom integrated in one app, is it automatically also available as a solution for other apps? So meaning, is it basically on device, or do I need an atom integration for each individual app?
It's an app.
Yeah. It's for each individual app.
Yeah.
Because each app is sandboxed and separate.
Yeah.
Good question.
Chris. Crisp question. Crisp answer. So, um, thanks a lot again to the tech expert. I think an extra round of applause is in order for them. Um.
Thank you.
It was a real pleasure listening to you. Thank you all.
Thank you.
Um, so we're reaching the end of today's Capital Markets Day. Um, before I hand you over to Remco, also from my side, um, a big thank you for attending today. It's no fun if there's nobody watching. Uh, so also to everybody online. Thanks for spending the time with us. And now for the famous last words. I'm handing you over to Remco again to, uh, close the session of the day.
Thanks. Thank you, Ingo, and thank you all for staying with us so long. And, uh, following us. Yes. Capital Markets Day is always a good opportunity. I mean, we do it once a year. It's a good point to really show where we are. I think today we were also able to show how complex this market is. That's also one of the challenges. And we provided you with a lot of information. So, our aim today was presenting our Q2 performance. Give you an update on what we have achieved since the last TMD. We're given a commercial and financial update. We explained our Q2 unification issue. And we went into our strategy, emphasizing our confidence about the future. And I hope we were able to not only show you our confidence, but also make our investors confident about the great future that this company has. We had external and internal experts. Thanks to Eric. Thanks to Paul, and thanks to Michelle for the deep dives. I hope we didn't confuse you too much because, as mentioned, it is complex. However, I hope we were able to educate, clarify, and help you understand this sector better. We continue our focus to make media better. We showed you our strategic initiatives: verticalization, multi-channel, privacy platform, unification, investment into sales, due expansion, strengthening the core team, and M&A if it fits, but mostly focus on organic growth. And where are we really building? USPs. As mentioned before, this market has a lot of players that don't have clear USPs and are just there because the market is big. If you want to drive, if you want to really be successful in this market, you need to build USPs. And with our ideal advertising potential, with our AI, with our strong supply base, with our strong demand. I think we have a very strong basis to further grow this company. In summary, we reached a key milestone with our in-app platform integration, and after it, I don't want to talk too much about it anymore. We further build on our strong direct supply position in-app, and we want to scale that to other platforms. We further invest in our sales teams. We continue to invest in our differentiation and we keep growing. We further grow. The target is really to reach the 1 billion. That's our next target. And after that, there will be another target. We want to achieve that in the next 3 to 5 years, and we're looking forward to it as well. I'm super proud of the team and the great presentations. We see that really this company is making big progress every year. This year's Capital Markets Day presentation was shorter than last year, even though it was still long. We would really appreciate your feedback because we only want to make this better. I would like to thank the speakers for participating, and not only the speakers, but also the team behind it and those here in the room, as they were not on stage. Today we have Samir, who is running the marketplace supply side. We have Alex running the strategy part, and we have Tobias Weitzel, our chairman of the board. Apart from the other people that you saw on stage. But the biggest thanks go to investors, analysts, and all the people that support us. Thank you very much. Thank you for supporting us. Thank you for going with us through ups and downs. And we had a bit of a downturn, but we're going up now and, um, yeah, super proud, super happy. And thank you all very much. That's the end of today.



















